The Expropriation Lesson

A Play
Cast
The Instructor  ·  The New Pharaoh  ·  Henry VIII
The Other Students  ·  The New Student  ·  The First Student

(A classroom at the Institute for the Advancement of Dictatorships. A whiteboard at the front. The students sit at small desks. Morning light falls across the lake. The Instructor stands by the whiteboard. On it, in large letters: MONEY.)

The Instructor

Today we talk about money.

Some of you will inherit it.

Some of you will take it.

The distinction, as you will learn, is largely ceremonial.

(He pauses.)

The Instructor

Some of you will remember our field trip to Cairo.

Our host on that occasion has kindly agreed to visit us today.

Please welcome the New Pharaoh.

(The New Pharaoh enters. He nods once. He does not smile. He takes a chair to the side — not at the front, not among the students. Slightly apart.)

The New Pharaoh

Good morning.

(The students echo his greeting.)

The Instructor

We are also joined today by a guest from another age.

A king. A reformer. A man who understood that the church was, above all, a balance sheet.

His Majesty, Henry the Eighth.

(Henry VIII enters. He is large. He looks at the whiteboard, then at the New Pharaoh, then at the students. He picks up a marker and adds, beneath MONEY, the word: MINE.)

The Instructor

Your Majesty, perhaps you could begin by telling the students how you approached the question of —

Henry VIII

I dissolved the monasteries.

The Instructor

Yes. And —

Henry VIII

All of them.

The Other Students

All of them.

Henry VIII

Eight hundred and eighty-six.

The New Student

On what grounds?

Henry VIII
(turning to look at him)

Corruption. Moral laxity. The will of God.

The New Student

Which was it?

Henry VIII

All three. In that order of convenience.

(The First Student looks at Henry VIII.)

The First Student

What did you take?

Henry VIII

Land. Buildings. Gold, silver, livestock. All of it. Overnight.

The New Pharaoh
(quietly)

Overnight is careless.

(A brief silence. Henry VIII turns to look at him.)

Henry VIII

I beg your pardon?

The New Pharaoh

It draws attention.

The Other Students

Attention.

The New Pharaoh

You wrote it on the board.

(He gestures toward the whiteboard.)

The New Pharaoh

That is the mistake.

Henry VIII

I took what was mine by right and by God.

The New Pharaoh

When you took it, everybody knew it.

(A pause.)

The New Student

Is that not unavoidable?

The New Pharaoh

No.

The New Student

But surely people see —

The New Pharaoh

There is nothing to see.

No villas. No yachts. No gold on the walls.

Nothing that was not there before.

The New Student

Then where does it go?

(The New Pharaoh looks at him for a moment.)

The New Pharaoh

That is precisely the point.

(He gestures at Henry VIII.)

The New Pharaoh

He was always going to be caught.

Henry VIII

I beg your pardon.

I am the Supreme Head of the Church of England.

I remade the law of this kingdom in my own image.

And you stand there and tell me I was careless.

(He pauses, breathing heavily.)

Henry VIII

In my time I would have had you arrested before breakfast.

Charged by noon.

Tried by evening.

And beheaded before the sun went down.

(A pause.)

Henry VIII

With an audience.

The New Pharaoh

Of course you would.

(The New Student turns to the New Pharaoh.)

The New Student

You have not told us yet where the money goes.

The New Pharaoh

And I will not.

But trust me, children, it is there.

And it is a lot.

More than he could ever dream of.

(Henry VIII looks at him.)

Henry VIII

Your suit looks so cheap.

The First Student

I think that might be the point, Your Majesty.

(The Instructor clears his throat.)

The Instructor

Gentlemen. Can we turn to taxation now?

Henry VIII
(brightening)

Taxation. Yes.

A fine instrument.

I taxed the clergy.

I taxed the merchants.

I taxed the peasants.

I taxed the peasants again.

The Other Students

Again.

Henry VIII

A kingdom runs on revenue.

Without revenue there is no navy.

Without a navy there is no kingdom.

It is very simple.

The New Student

And did they pay?

Henry VIII

Not always willingly.

The First Student

There were rebellions.

Henry VIII

There were suppressions.

(The New Student turns to the New Pharaoh.)

The New Student

And you? What do you tax?

The New Pharaoh
(a brief pause)

We do not tax.

We subsidise.

The New Student

I do not understand.

The New Pharaoh

We subsidise.

Fuel. Bread.

The New Student

But then how —

Henry VIII
(unable to contain himself)

You do not tax?

The New Pharaoh

No.

Henry VIII

Not at all?

The New Pharaoh

Not meaningfully.

Henry VIII

But how do you fund your navy?

The New Pharaoh

We have no navy worth speaking of.

Henry VIII

Your armies then.

The New Pharaoh

My armies have interests.

Henry VIII

What kind of interests?

The New Pharaoh

Various.

(A pause.)

The New Pharaoh

They build things.

They sell things.

Everybody is kept busy.

And everybody is content.

Henry VIII

I don't understand you at all.

The New Pharaoh

I know.

The New Student

In my mother's country, people are taxed.

Heavily, sometimes.

She was elected on a promise to tax the rich.

And she kept that promise.

The New Pharaoh

I was elected as well.

Henry VIII

Elected?

The New Pharaoh

Twice.

(The New Pharaoh turns to the New Student.)

The New Pharaoh

And if I may —

your mother is playing a dangerous game.

You want the rich by your side.

Henry VIII

I made people rich.

The New Pharaoh

Finally we have something in common.

(The First Student leans toward the New Student and whispers.)

The First Student

Your best friends are friends that depend on you.