a farmer, a rancher, a brook between them, and cows that do not care about brooks.
hear six quarrels between neighbours. tap a ruling. watch what the neighbours do with it. the first quarrel comes back the year after, so you can try another sign.
rule on six quarrels so the valley is worth the most.
rule on six quarrels so the valley is worth the most.
your ruling. touch one to read it on the sign, then press rule.
the other two rulings would have ended with:
the verdict
the valley is measured in dollars because coase measures it so: the value of what gets produced. he says himself that the real choice between arrangements is wider than that, and takes in "all spheres of life".
how to play
rule on six quarrels so the valley is worth the most.
six quarrels come to you, one at a time. each is two neighbours and a harm: cows that eat corn, a chimney that spoils washing, a railway whose sparks burn fields. you are the judge. the first quarrel comes back a year later, and you rule on it again with a different sign: that second year is for seeing what changes, and it does not count.
the picture
the valley is drawn at the top. the one doing the harm is on the right (the rancher, the works, the railway); the one harmed is on the left (the farmer, the houses, the farms). the signpost on the bank is where your ruling will stand.
the facts
four cards under the picture say what each thing is worth: what each cow brings in, what the corn is worth and how much of it the cows eat, what a fence, a filter or a clothes horse costs, and whether the neighbours can talk, for free, through a lawyer, or not at all. you need these to rule well: the valley's worth is what both neighbours produce, less what the harm spoils and what any fence, filter, clothes horse or lawyer costs.
the ruling
three rulings, every time: the harmer may carry on; the harmer must pay for the harm; the harmful thing is banned here. touch one and the sign on the bank shows it, with a line saying what each neighbour now owes or holds. nothing yet says what they will do with it. press rule to commit.
what happens
press next to watch the neighbours act on your ruling, one step at a time: who plants what, who keeps how many cows, who pays whom, whether a deal is struck. a deal can only be struck if the neighbours can talk and the deal is worth more than talking costs.
the tally
three money bags: the harmed neighbour's purse, the harmer's purse, and the valley's chest, which is both together less any fee. the bar shows the valley's worth against the most any ruling could have got for this quarrel. the rulings you did not give are shown as dashed cards, with what they would have ended in.
the end
after six quarrels, the verdict: in how many quarrels your ruling got the most any ruling could, and where it did not, why; what the paper says; and what that means. then rule again, and try the other rulings.
about
Coase's Cows is a game built from Ronald H. Coase, "The Problem of Social Cost", Journal of Law and Economics 3 (October 1960): 1–44. DOI 10.1086/466560. On JSTOR as stable 724810. Game built from this paper; the paper is the authority where the two disagree.
what the paper says
Harm between neighbours is reciprocal: to stop the rancher's cattle harming the farmer's crops is to harm the rancher. The question is not "how do we restrain A?" but "which harm is the smaller?" If the two can bargain for free, it does not matter whom the law protects: the cattle-raiser who must pay for trampled corn and the cattle-raiser who may be paid to keep a steer at home face the same cost of the third steer, and the same herd results. The ruling changes who pays whom and nothing else. But bargaining is never free, and once it costs something the ruling does decide what happens; the choice is then among whole arrangements (the market, the firm, direct regulation, doing nothing), each of which costs something, and the right one is the one with the largest total product. The reflex of making the harmer pay can make things worse: in Coase's railway example, liability for sparks leads the farmers to plant the strip beside the line, which burns, and no train pays for its sparks; the trains stop and the valley is poorer.
what the game does with it
You are the court. Six quarrels come to you: the paper's own farmer and cattle-raiser (sections III–IV), the strip the cows cross to drink (section III), the cost of bargaining (section V and footnote 4), the smoke nuisance with its vast number of sufferers, its smoke-preventing device, and the sufferers' own cheaper way out of the smoke (section V, p. 9, and the reciprocal nature of harm of section II), the railway with Coase's own figures (section VII), and the same railway with other figures, as Coase says other figures would make liability right (p. 17). Each time, the paper's three courses of action from its first paragraph are your rulings: liability, no liability, or exclusion. Touch one to read it on the sign; press rule; watch the neighbours act on it. The first quarrel comes back a year later and is ruled a second time with a different sign, as the paper itself rules its farmer and cattle-raiser twice: the second year is not scored, the comparison is the point.
mechanism kind: ported, with a toy on top
The two arithmetical examples are ported with Coase's numbers: crop loss of 1, 3, 6 and 10 tons for herds of one to four at $1 a ton; a $9 fence; a tract worth $12 that costs $10 to grow; one train worth $150 at a cost of $50, two worth $250 at $100; $60 of crops burnt a train, doubling to $120 under liability as the strip by the line is planted; $160 of crops on the abandoned land against $150 of released factors. Around them the game adds what the paper leaves out and tags as its own in the config block of the source: the meat each steer brings ($5, $4, $1, and a fourth that loses $1, so that the unconstrained herd is three, as Coase says); the corn's worth in the first quarrel ($8); the lawyer's fee ($3); turnips ($6); the chimney's figures ($20 to run, $15 of washing, a $12 filter for the works, $5 of clothes horses across a hundred houses); the orchard's ($300 standing, $200 of sparks a train); and an even split of the surplus from any bargain, where Coase says the split would depend on the shrewdness of the bargainers.
The game demonstrates that under Coase's arithmetic, with free bargaining, every ruling but the ban ends in the same herd and the same value, with the money running the other way; that a cost of bargaining makes the ruling matter; that where the cheap way out of a harm lies with the sufferers, protecting them puts the fix on the dear side (the works buys a $12 filter because it cannot buy $5 of clothes horses from a hundred houses); and that with his railway figures, liability stops the trains and lowers the total, while with other figures it is right. The game assumes the numbers it added, that neighbours who can bargain reach the best arrangement and split the gain evenly, that a hundred households or a hundred farms cannot bargain at all, and that the valley's worth is the value of what gets produced. The paper establishes the argument and the two examples as arithmetic, not as facts about any valley: it does not measure a lawyer's fee or a filter's price, and it says itself that the choice between arrangements should be made in broader terms than the value of production.
Where the game's discoveries come from: the tie between rulings in the first two quarrels follows from the paper's mechanism and from no number we chose (the calibration check reproduces it for three hundred random meat and corn values). The railway's reversal follows from Coase's own figures and holds for any standing crop on the far fields and for a strip worth up to $29; at $30 or more the ruling flips, which is Coase's "by altering the figures" remark and is played as the sixth quarrel. The lawyer's quarrel splits for any fee above the $2 a deal would gain. The yardstick, the value of the valley against the most any ruling could get, is the paper's own criterion. The verdict counts the quarrels in which the ruling got the most, rather than summing dollars, because the far fields' $200 standing crop (ours) would otherwise let the fair instinct, make the harmer pay every time, score $571 of $600 while missing three quarrels of six; the fate in words is ours.
what is cut
The confectioner and the doctor, and the case law of section VI; the firm as an arrangement; a Pigovian tax as a fourth ruling; Pigou's rabbits and Boulston's case (the temptation to draw a rabbit was resisted); the strategic preliminaries, which Coase says do not affect the long-run position; and the comparison of arrangements in anything but dollars, which Coase says is the real one.
the look
A picture book in the manner of Dick Bruna: a white page, one heavy black line, flat colour, everything reduced to the shapes a four-year-old recognises, all in lowercase. In the manner of, not the character. The paper's subject is a child's first farm, and the paper's argument is about where a line is drawn; the signpost is where the law stands. Type: Nunito (Vernon Adams and Cyreal, SIL Open Font License), embedded.
Steffen Huck, 2026. Built with Claude under the paper-to-game skill. The source, the design memo, the mechanism and its calibration check are in the repository.