paper-to-game

Coase’s Cows — design memo

0. Given

Mine: Steffen’s signature and counter. Author title. Ideas given, after a discussion of the look before anything was built: “it’s such an iconic paper but we want to keep some playfulness. so perhaps ligne claire? or perhaps even better some childlike drawings?” The engine put three candidates up (a Dick Bruna picture book, a Fuzzy-Felt farm board, Richard Scarry’s Busytown) and argued for Bruna; Steffen’s own tendency, revealed afterwards, was the same: “that aligns with my thing after looking more at bruna. so lets go!!!” So the chassis is fixed by the Given: a picture book in the manner of Dick Bruna. This overrides the precedent rule twice, and the memo says so here: the register family (Drawn) is the family of Me and My Friends, two games back, and the idiom is a cousin of the ligne claire of Curie’s Counterfactuals, which is older than the last three. Both overrides were discussed and chosen on purpose (section 13 says what is different from each). Everything else is the engine’s.

1. Paper

Ronald H. Coase, “The Problem of Social Cost”, Journal of Law and Economics 3 (October 1960): 1–44. DOI 10.1086/466560. Available: a 23-page typeset reprint (PDF only; the case-law discussion of section VI is abbreviated in it with an ellipsis, and sections IX and X of the original, the Pigovian tradition and the change of approach’s second half, are not in it; section VIII is). The reprint is OCR’d: the herd table on p. 2 prints “Z” for 2, and no number in it was trusted without being read twice against Coase’s prose, where every number of the two arithmetical examples is also stated in words. Online: JSTOR (stable 724810) and the University of Chicago Press. No code, no data: the paper is an argument with two worked arithmetical examples, which is what the game is built on.

2. What the paper hands over

Primary: an argument. (i) Harm is reciprocal: to stop A harming B is to harm A, so the question is not “how do we restrain A?” but “which harm is the lesser?” (section II). (ii) If bargaining is costless, the legal assignment of liability does not change what gets produced, only who pays whom: the cattle-raiser who must pay for trampled crops and the cattle-raiser who may be paid to keep a steer at home face the same cost of the third steer (sections III–IV). (iii) Bargaining is not costless, and once it is not, the initial assignment of rights does decide the outcome, and the alternatives (the market, the firm, direct regulation, doing nothing) all cost something, so the choice is among whole social arrangements by their total product (sections V–VI). (iv) The Pigovian reflex (make the harmer pay, or tax him) can therefore make things worse, as it does in the railway example, where liability stops the trains and the farmers plant the strip that burns (section VII). (v) The change of approach: compare the total product of alternative arrangements, starting from where we are (section VIII).

Secondary: two arithmetical examples, ported. The farmer and the cattle-raiser: crop loss of 1, 3, 6 and 10 tons for herds of 1 to 4 steers at $1 a ton, so marginal damage 1, 2, 3, 4; a fence at $9 a year; a tract whose crop is worth $12 and costs $10 to grow, net $2; a strip worth $10 costing $11; footnote 4’s crop that pays $1 instead of $2 and takes $1 of damage instead of $3. The railway: one train a day is worth $150 and costs $50, two are worth $250 and cost $100; one train burns $60 of crops, two burn $120; under liability the farmers plant the land by the line too, and the damage doubles to $120 and $240; the abandoned land would have grown $160 of crops but releases $150 of labour and capital to be used elsewhere, so running the railway unliable is worth $20 more than no railway, and liability shuts it. The paper gives no meat values for the steers; the game supplies them and tags them as ours.

3. The discovery, and its kind

A counterintuitive result, twice. First: the public and the field believed that the one who causes the harm should pay; Coase shows that when neighbours can talk, making him pay changes who pays whom and nothing else, and that the “victim” may end up paid to give way. Second: when neighbours cannot talk, the reflex of making the harmer pay can lower the total: the railway stops. Underneath both, a mechanism made intelligible: bargaining over a right, and the cost of bargaining as the thing that makes the law matter.

4. The core narrative

A farmer grows corn on one side of a brook, and a rancher keeps cows on the other, and the cows walk over and eat the corn. The two of them come to you, the judge, and ask who is in the right. You say: the cows may roam. The farmer goes home, thinks, and offers the rancher a few dollars to keep his third cow at home, because the corn that cow eats is worth more than the cow. Next year you say the opposite: the corn is protected, the rancher must pay for every ear. And the rancher keeps two cows, exactly as before. Your ruling changed who paid whom and nothing else. Then the quarrels get bigger: a lawyer who charges for every deal, a hundred houses under one chimney, a railway whose sparks burn the fields along the line. Now nobody can make a deal, your ruling decides what happens, and the one that feels fair (the railway must pay) stops the trains and leaves everyone poorer. The right ruling is the one that counts the whole valley.

5. Who lives in the paper

6. Precedent

  Position Format Feedback device Chassis
Dear Household controller (a town’s planner) challenge with a discovery inside sightlines between two streets, gardens filling with saplings, an expectation marker Retro: a 1970s British public-information poster; cream, forest, leaf, marigold; Fredoka; solid poster blocks; light
Me and My Friends agent (the parents of a street) after a country-building prologue a challenge that cannot be met the crossing: a child’s drawing of a playground with red lines across the middle, a crayon ruler Drawn: crayon on buff sugar paper; wax black, crayon red, three crayons; Gloria Hallelujah + Patrick Hand; wobbly rectangles
One Number, Please experimenter (running the lab) discovery closed by a written reply the subjects’ own screen redrawn live, a lab notebook filling Retro: a z-Tree terminal on Windows 2000; dialog grey, title navy, lab red; Liberation Sans; bevelled push buttons

What this game does differently. Position: the judge, who rules on who may harm whom; the paper’s own court of section VI. Neither a planner, nor a parent answering a survey, nor an experimenter; no game in the table has put the player on the bench. Format: strategic, in the skill’s sense: the player rules and two neighbours react to the ruling (they adjust, they bargain, or they cannot), and the player learns to anticipate what they will do with it. Not a challenge with an unreachable target, not a discovery closed by a reply. Device: one of our own, the sign and the purses: the ruling goes up as a sign in the field, the valley picture redraws as the neighbours act on it (cows cross or stay, corn is eaten or planted, a fence is drawn, coins pass from one purse to the other), and the valley’s worth is shown against the most any ruling could get; nothing fills with saplings, no crayon ruler, no notebook. Chassis: a Dick Bruna picture book (Drawn), by the Given: white page, one heavy black line, five flat colours, a rounded sans in lowercase. Same family as Me and My Friends (the Given overrides the family rule, section 0) but nothing of its surface: no crayon, no texture, no wobble, no buff, no hand-lettering; everything straight-edged and flat on white. Not the Fredoka poster, not the Windows dialog.

7. The aim and the verdict

Aim, on the start screen, at the top of the play screen, and first in How to play: rule on six quarrels so the valley is worth the most.

The yardstick is in the aim’s units: after each quarrel, what the valley is worth under the player’s ruling, in dollars, beside the most any ruling could have got for that quarrel; at the end, the sum of the six against the sum of the six bests.

Verdict (the end screen leads with these, in words):

A fate in words follows (section 11), and the paper’s own caveat: the valley is measured in dollars because Coase measures it so, and he says himself that the real choice is wider than that.

8. Three concepts

A. The Rancher (agent; strategic). The player is the cattle-raiser. Each season the court hands down a law (cows may roam / corn protected) and the player picks the herd, one to four steers, seeing the meat each steer brings and the corn each eats. The farmer (the mechanism) reacts: pays for a steer to stay home, or sends a bill, or gives up the strip. Deliberation: how many steers, given the law and the farmer’s likely offer. Discovery: under either law the player ends with the same herd and the money runs the other way. Fun: agency, mastery (the second season’s herd is picked faster), discovery. Second playthrough: play the other law. Weakness: the deliberation is arithmetic with the numbers on screen; the law is handed to the player instead of chosen; and the railway and the chimney, where the paper’s second discovery lives, cannot be played from the saddle.

B. The Judge (dilemma / agent; strategic). The pick. The player is the court. Six quarrels come to the bench, each a pair of neighbours and a harm, with the facts in pictures: what each cow brings, what each eats, what a fence costs, whether the neighbours can talk and what talking costs. Three rulings, the paper’s own three courses (p. 1): the harmer may carry on; the harmer must pay for the harm; the harmful thing is banned here. Touching a ruling puts its sign up in the field and says what it means; “rule” commits. The neighbours then act on the ruling, beat by beat, in the picture: cows cross, the farmer plants or gives up, a fence goes up, a deal is struck and coins pass, or no deal can be made and the lawyer’s fee or the hundred households say why. Then the valley’s worth against the most any ruling could get, and the other two rulings as ghost lines. Deliberation: who deserves the right, at first; then, once talking costs, which ruling leaves the valley best without a deal; then, with the railway, what the whole valley is worth under each ruling, including the strip that gets planted because it pays either way. Discovery: quarrels one and two, the ruling changes who pays whom and nothing else, and the protected farmer is paid to give way; quarrel three, the ruling begins to matter; quarrel five, making the railway pay stops the trains and the valley is poorer. Fun: anticipation (what will they do with it?), discovery, mastery (by the chimney the player is reading the facts the way Coase reads them), agency. Second playthrough: rule the other way on every quarrel and watch the purses change where the valley does not, and the valley change where it does.

C. Two Thumbs (agent, both at once; reckless). No words on the play screen. The player’s left thumb drags cows one by one over the brook; the right thumb drags corn rows into the field; two purses fill and empty as coins fly between the two neighbours’ faces; a gavel in the corner flips the law, and nothing in the field changes when it does, only the direction of the coins. The player finds the arrangement with the most coins in the valley’s chest by feel. Deliberation: pattern and experiment. Discovery: the gavel changes nothing. Fun: agency, discovery. Second playthrough: a different valley. Written out in full below; it loses because the gavel’s indifference is the paper’s first half only and a wordless screen cannot stage the second half (the cost of talking, the hundred households, the strip that gets planted), which is where the paper’s harder discovery lies; and because without words the player infers prices from coin animations, which is reading a sentence in a worse language.

9. The first five minutes

B, the pick. 0:00. A white page. A brown cow with two dot eyes and a farmer with a round head, side by side, both looking out. “coase’s cows.” One line: “a farmer, a rancher, a brook between them, and cows that do not care about brooks.” Under it: “hear six quarrels. tap a ruling. watch what the neighbours do with it.” The aim. A big red “begin”. 0:20. Quarrel 1 of 6. Left: corn in rows, a farmer. Right: three cows, a rancher. A brook down the middle, and a blank signpost on the bank. Under the picture, four fact cards, each a picture and a number: a row of four cows with “$5 $4 $2 −$1” (what each cow brings in meat); the corn “worth $8; each cow eats $1, then $2, then $3, then $4 of it”; a fence “$9”; two faces over the brook, “they can talk for free”. Three rulings in Bruna frames: “the cows may roam”, “the corn is protected: the rancher pays for what the cows eat”, “no cows on this side of the brook”. The stranger thinks: the cows eat the corn, so the corn is protected, obviously. They touch it. The sign on the bank reads “corn protected”, and a line: “the rancher owes the farmer the price of every ear his cows eat.” They press rule. 0:50. Beat: the sign goes up. Beat: the rancher counts: a third cow brings $2 and eats $3 of corn, so he keeps two; the third cow walks back off the picture. Beat: two cows cross, $3 of corn is eaten (three ears turn to stubble), three coins fly from the rancher’s purse to the farmer’s. Tally: farmer $11, rancher $6, the valley $14, and a bar: “the most any ruling could get: $14”. Then the ghost lines: “had the cows been allowed to roam: the rancher keeps three, the farmer pays him $2 or so to send one home; two cows, valley $14. had cows been banned: valley $8.” The stranger frowns: the farmer would have paid the rancher? And it comes to the same? 1:40. Quarrel 2: the same two, a poor strip by the brook where the cows go to drink, the corn worth only $2. The stranger, suspicious now, tries “the cows may roam” to see. Beat: the rancher keeps three. Beat: the farmer looks at $2 of corn and $6 of damage and does not plant; the strip goes green. Valley $11, the most. Ghost: “had the corn been protected: the farmer plants, the rancher offers him $2 and a bit to stop, and he takes it; the strip goes green anyway; valley $11.” The stranger grins: the protected farmer is paid to give up. 2:30. Quarrel 3: a lawyer stands on the bank with a price tag, “$3 for any deal”. The farmer could grow turnips instead (“cows won’t touch them; worth $6”). Now the stranger has to think: if the corn is protected, the farmer plants corn and waits for his money, the rancher keeps two cows, and nobody pays a lawyer $3 to fix it, valley $14; if the cows may roam, the farmer plants turnips himself, the rancher keeps three, valley $17. They rule for the cows. It works. 3:30. Quarrel 4: a chimney and a hundred little houses, “a hundred households: no deal can be made”. The stranger, having learnt “let them roam”, hesitates: who can fix it cheaply? The factory, a filter for $5. They rule “protected” and the filter goes on; valley at its best. 4:15. Quarrel 5: a railway, a hundred farms along the line, no deal possible. A train is worth $150 and costs $50, burns $60 of crops; a second is worth $100 more and burns $60 more; and a line in the facts: “the strip beside the line is worth $10 planted, and burns $60 a train; the farmers plant it only if someone pays for the burning.” The stranger weighs it. Make the railway pay? Beat: the farmers plant the strip (“it pays either way”). Beat: one train would owe $120 and earn $100; no trains run. Valley $210, “the most any ruling could get: $230”. Ghost: “had the railway been let spark: two trains, the strip left unplanted, the far fields burnt for $120, valley $230; one train would have been best of all, $240, but no ruling gets that.” The frown, then the grin: the fair ruling stopped the trains. 5:15. Quarrel 6: the same railway through orchards worth $300, sparks burn $200 a train. The stranger, now reading the totals, makes the railway pay, and the orchards stand. Verdict.

A, the runner-up. 0:00. The same cover. “you are the rancher.” 0:20. Season 1, the law: “the corn is protected: you pay for what your cows eat.” Four cows in a row with their meat values, the corn’s damage per cow; a slider from 0 to 4. The stranger counts: the third cow earns $2 and costs $3; two cows. They commit. The farmer sends a bill for $3. Purse $6. 1:00. Season 2, the law flips: “the cows may roam.” The stranger sets three cows. The farmer comes to the fence: “I’ll give you $2.50 to keep the third at home.” The stranger thinks: the third cow brings $2; yes. Purse $11.50 − … they notice: two cows again. 1:40. Seasons 3 and 4 add the lawyer and the turnips; the stranger’s job is still to pick a herd, and the farmer’s reactions carry the lesson. 3:00. The railway cannot be played; it is read on the verdict screen. The stranger has had an arithmetic exercise with a twist in the second season and a reading at the end.

10. The pick, and why

B, The Judge. It is the paper’s own question handed to the player: “should A be allowed to harm B or should B be allowed to harm A?” (p. 1), asked six times with the paper’s own cases, and the player’s first instinct is Pigou’s. Both of the paper’s discoveries land inside play, the first by quarrel two and the second at quarrel five, and the rulings in between carry real deliberation about the thing the paper is actually about: whether the neighbours can talk, and at what price. The sentence afterwards has no “guess”: I protected the corn and the rancher kept two cows; I let the cows roam and the rancher kept two cows; I protected the strip and the farmer was paid to give it up; I made the railway pay and the trains stopped. Originality: no game in the table has put the player on the bench, and none has made the cost of a deal the thing the player learns to read.

Author test. Coase would enjoy watching a stranger rule for the corn, see the purses swap and the herd stay, rule for the cows next time to test it, and then be caught by the railway. The quarrels are his own arithmetic, in his order of difficulty rather than his order of exposition, and the verdict’s caveat is his own section VIII.

Runner-up: A, The Rancher. Switch if the author wants the player to feel the cost of the third steer in their own purse rather than see it on a ledger, and accepts losing the railway as play.

What the reckless concept would have given. Kept: the coins flying between the two purses as the deal is struck, and the sign in the field as the whole statement of the law, which came from imagining a screen with no words. Given up: the silence, and the thumbs.

11. The shape

Six quarrels, one screen each with a result sequence; then the verdict. About five to seven minutes, an estimate. Each quarrel is one of the paper’s cases, ordered for the player:

  1. The cows and the corn (section III–IV; marginal damage 1, 2, 3, 4; fence $9; meat values ours; the corn’s worth ours at $8 so that both neighbours stay). Talking free. Discovery one: the ruling changes who pays whom.
  2. The strip by the brook (section III: the tract worth $12 costing $10, net $2, “the cattle have a well-defined route, say, to a brook”). Talking free. The protected farmer is paid to give way.
  3. The lawyer (section V, the costs of market transactions, and footnote 4, the crop that cows do not eat). A deal costs $3. The ruling begins to matter: the right should go where no deal is needed.
  4. The chimney (section V, the smoke nuisance “which may affect a vast number of people”, the smoke-preventing device). No deal possible. The harmer can fix it cheaply: making him pay works.
  5. Sparks (section VII, Coase’s railway numbers). No deal possible. Making the railway pay stops the trains; letting it spark is better; one train would be best and no ruling gets it.
  6. The orchard (section VII: “by altering the figures, it could be shown that there are other cases in which it would be desirable that the railway should be liable”; numbers ours). No deal possible. Letting it spark burns the orchard; making it pay is right.

Score: the valley’s worth under the player’s ruling against the most any of the three rulings could get, per quarrel and summed at the end. The criterion is the paper’s own (the value of production, sections V–VIII), and the About screen says that Coase himself calls it narrower than the real choice. Fates in words at the end, by the share of the possible: all six at their best, “the valley paints your face on the signpost”; most, “the farmer and the rancher both send you a card. so does the railway.”; about half, “the valley is doing all right, and nobody is sure whose fault that is”; less, “the cows have asked for a new judge”. A last screen reads the paper’s change of approach. No retry past the sixth quarrel; “rule again” starts a new run.

12. Controls, mechanism, feedback, moment

Controls. One: the ruling, three live options on every quarrel (the harmer may carry on / the harmer must pay / the harmful thing is banned here), which are the paper’s own three courses of action from its first paragraph (liability, a tax on the damage equivalent to it, exclusion from the district). Touching one previews it: the sign on the bank changes and one line says what the ruling means for the two neighbours (what each now owes or holds); nothing about what they will do with it, nothing about the valley’s worth. “rule” commits. Every quarrel starts with no ruling selected.

Mechanism (mechanism.js, ported from the two examples and generalised): a quarrel is a harmer with activity levels and a marginal profit for each (steers, trains, the machine), a sufferer with one or more plots each with a standalone worth and a damage per unit of activity (and, in quarrel 3, a second crop with no damage), a device (fence, filter) at a price that removes the damage and can be bought by either side, and a cost of talking (free, a fee, or impossible). Under each ruling the mechanism computes the status quo (each side’s own best move given the law, the sufferer’s planting decided by what he keeps: all of the plot’s worth if protected, the worth less the damage if not), the efficient arrangement (the maximum of the valley’s worth over everything both sides could do), and the deal: if the gain from moving from the status quo to the efficient arrangement exceeds the cost of talking, they move, the fee is paid, and the surplus net of the fee is split evenly (Coase: “would depend on the shrewdness of the farmer and the cattle-raiser as bargainers”; the even split is ours), the loser compensated first. The ban sets the activity to zero and allows no deal (a decree, section V). The output is a list of beats, each a state of the picture and one line in the game’s voice, plus the purses and the valley’s worth, for the player’s ruling and for the two others.

Feedback. The sign and the purses (section 6): the valley picture redraws beat by beat, coins pass, and the valley’s worth is drawn as a bar against the most any ruling could get, with the two other rulings as ghost lines beneath.

Moment. Quarrel 2’s ghost line, or its played line: the farmer whose corn the court protected takes the rancher’s money and leaves the strip unplanted; and quarrel 5’s beat: “no trains run.”

13. The look

Register: a picture book in the manner of Dick Bruna (Drawn family; by the Given, and the discussion in section 0). From the paper’s subject, which is a child’s first farm: cows, corn, a fence, a train, a chimney; and from the paper’s temperament: one clean line, the fewest marks, and an argument about where a line is drawn. Bruna’s idiom: a white page; one heavy, even black outline round everything; flat colour inside it and no shading, no texture, no perspective; figures frontal and centred, eyes two dots, a mouth one short line or a small cross; objects reduced to the two or three shapes a four-year-old recognises; all text in lowercase. In the manner of, not the character: no rabbit, no Miffy (though Coase has rabbits in section VII, and the About screen says the temptation was resisted).

14. What is cut

The confectioner and the doctor (Sturges v. Bridgman) and the whole case-law of section VI; the firm as an arrangement (it is named on About); the Pigovian tax as a fourth ruling (it is the second ruling with the money going to the state, and the game keeps three); Pigou’s rabbits and Boulston’s case; the strategic preliminaries (a rancher who grows his herd to be paid more, a farmer who plants to be bought off), which Coase says do not affect the long-run position; the comparison of total social product in anything but dollars, which Coase says is the real one and which the About screen quotes him on.

15. Divergences

16. Mechanism kind and claim boundaries

Kind: ported, with a toy around it. The two arithmetical examples run with Coase’s own numbers (the crop-loss column, the $9 fence, the $12 crop costing $10, the railway’s $150/$50 and $250/$100, the $60 a train that doubles to $120 under liability, the $160 of crops against $150 of released factors), and the game generalises them into one structure (a harmer with marginal profits, a sufferer with plots, a device, a cost of talking) so that the six quarrels are instances of one mechanism. What the paper does not give, the game adds and tags as ours in CONFIG: the steers’ meat values, the corn’s worth in quarrel 1, the lawyer’s fee and the turnips, the chimney’s three figures, the orchard’s two, the even split of a bargain’s surplus, and the fate bands.

Where the discoveries come from (build.md §1). Discovery one (the tie between rulings when talking is free) follows from the mechanism, not from any chosen number: the calibration check reproduces it for 300 random meat and corn values. Discovery two (the lawyer: the ruling matters) follows from the fee exceeding the gain, and holds for any fee above $2; at a fee of zero the rulings tie again. Discovery three (the railway: liability stops the trains, and letting it spark is better) is Coase’s own figures and holds for any standing crop on the far fields (our one added number there) and for a strip worth up to $29; at $30 and above the ruling flips, which is what Coase says altered figures would do, and the game plays that as quarrel 6 rather than hiding it. The chimney’s result (liability gets the filter fitted) rests on our figures and on the device being the works’ alone to fit; the About screen says so. The score is the paper’s criterion; the fate in words, by each valley’s share of the possible counted equally, is ours, and the loop table shows it ranks the obvious strategies as the paper would (section 18).

The two traps. No correlation is played as a cause: the mechanism is a model, and every lever is a variable in Coase’s own model. No average is played as an individual: there are no averages.

17. Calibration plan and result

Checked headlessly (calibration.js, 120 checks, calibration-result.txt, all passing) against the paper’s stated numbers and claims: the crop-loss column (p. 2); the unconstrained herd of three (p. 6); the fence beating damage only at four steers (p. 3); liable, two steers and $3 of damages (p. 6); not liable, the farmer’s payment between the steer’s $1 of meat and the $3 of corn it eats (p. 6); the same herd and the same value of production under either rule (pp. 6–7); the money running the other way (p. 7); the strip: net gain $2, a bargain to abandon cultivation under liability with a payment above $2 (pp. 3–4), the same bare strip under no liability, and a change in the distribution of income but not the allocation (p. 4); the lawyer: no rearrangement when the fee exceeds the gain and the delimitation of rights then affecting the value of production (section V), the undamaged crop planted when the farmer bears the damage (footnote 4); the chimney: the smoke-preventing device fitted under liability, no deal among a vast number of people, the decree worse than liability here (p. 9); the railway: $150/$50 and $250/$100, $60 and $120 of burning, two trains when not liable, the second train lowering total production, the strip planted and damage doubled under liability, no train paying, the strip abandoned when not liable, the railway worth $20 more than no railway, “it is better that the railway should not be liable”, and the better world of one train that no ruling reaches (pp. 15–17); the orchard: liability right with altered figures (p. 17). Then accounting on every quarrel and ruling (purses plus fee equal the valley; whole dollars; no decimals in any beat; the valley’s worth equal to the arrangement’s less the fee), the four robustness checks of section 16 and the flip at a strip worth $40, and a full run through the game API (six rulings finish a game; the verdict sums 580 of 600 for the fair instinct; the best ruling every time gets the first fate).

18. Playing it in numbers (build.md §3)

The obvious ways of ruling, run against the mechanism before any screen existed (loop.js, loop-log.txt); the share is each valley’s fraction of the possible, counted equally:

strategy per quarrel (yours / best) total / possible share fate
the fair instinct: make the harmer pay, every time 14/14 10/10 14/16 30/30 210/230 300/300 578/600 96% cards from the farmer, the rancher and the railway
let them carry on, every time 14/14 10/10 16/16 20/30 230/230 150/300 440/600 86% doing all right
ban the harmful thing, every time 8/14 2/10 8/16 15/30 210/230 300/300 543/600 61% the cows have asked for a new judge
pay in the farm, let the big ones spark 14/14 10/10 14/16 20/30 230/230 150/300 438/600 84% doing all right
Coase overlearned: pay until the lawyer, then let them be 14/14 10/10 16/16 20/30 230/230 150/300 440/600 86% doing all right
the paper’s reading: the best ruling each time all at the best 600/600 100% your face on the signpost
ruling by coin 14/14 2/10 14/16 20/30 210/230 300/300 560/600 78% doing all right

The decisions matter where the paper says they do and nowhere else: quarrels 1 and 2 tie between the two live rulings, and the ban loses; the fair instinct loses only on the lawyer and the railway; letting everyone carry on loses on the chimney and the orchard; banning everything loses on every farm. No one simple rule wins everywhere, which is the sentence the player should leave with: count the valley every time. The fate was switched from the dollar sum to the mean share after this table, because by dollars “ban everything” scored 91% on the strength of the railway’s hundreds while wrecking every farm.

19. Build log

15. Revision 1 (15 Nov 2026, in chat, after the author’s inspection)

Four findings on inspection, all built. (1) The verdict rewarded the fair instinct: “make the harmer pay, every time” scored $578 of $600 and got the card from everyone, because in four quarrels of six the fair ruling was best or tied and the far fields’ $200 standing crop (ours) made the two misses look small. The verdict now counts the quarrels in which the ruling got the most any ruling could (the first quarrel by its first year), names each miss and why, and says in one line where the ruling that felt fair was the wrong one; the dollar sum is still shown and no longer scores. (2) The Coase theorem was announced by a ghost card after one ruling; the paper itself rules its farmer and cattle-raiser twice. The first quarrel now comes back a year on: last year’s sign greyed out, the player rules again, the tally shows the two signs side by side with the same valley and the money the other way (or, if one year was the ban, what the ban cost and that the sign not tried ends the same way as the other). Year one withholds its ghost cards; the year after is not scored. (3) The chimney confirmed the reflex: only the works could fit the filter, so protecting the houses was right, which is the least-cost-avoider point rather than Coase’s. It is rebuilt on section II and p. 9 (“whether the factory should install smoke-preventing devices, or whether the occupants should move”): each house can buy a clothes horse for a few cents, $5 across the town and nothing to agree on; the filter costs $12. Let it smoke, and every house dries indoors: $30. Protect the houses, and the works buys the filter, because it cannot buy the cheap fix from a hundred houses: $23. Ban, $15. Now three quarrels of six turn against the fair ruling instead of two, each for a reason that is on the facts cards. (4) The strip under liability said “the rancher pays the farmer $3 for the damage” and then “offers the farmer $3 to leave the strip unplanted”, which reads as $6; where a deal follows, the damages are now a yearly prospect (“every year, the rancher would owe…”, “rather than that, …”) and only the deal’s coins fly. Found on the way: the deal’s coins flew from payee to payer; fixed. The device model is generalised (deviceA, deviceB; the fence is one fence either side could build) so that the mechanism, not a special case, produces the chimney. Calibration: 131 checks, all passing, including the fair instinct finding three of six and “let them carry on” missing the orchard.