Goodall’s Long Grass — design memo
0. Given
Steffen’s own: the game carries his signature and counter. One idea given, and it binds the look: the paper’s own figures: pencil drawings traced from photographs, grey graphite on cream paper, soft and exact; squared field-notebook pages, binocular circles, long grass; nothing comic. That is a register from the Drawn family (the hand-drawn notebook, the scientific drawing “from photo by…”). The game before last, Curie’s Counterfactuals, was also Drawn (a ligne claire comic), so the Given overrides the precedent rule’s “register family differs” here; palette, type, buttons and the visual rule still differ from all three (section 6). The Given’s “nothing comic” also rules out every comic device Curie used: no balloons, no emanata, no flat colour.
1. Paper
Jane van Lawick-Goodall, “Tool-Using in Primates and Other Vertebrates”. In D. S. Lehrman, R. A. Hinde and E. Shaw (eds.), Advances in the Study of Behavior, vol. 3 (New York: Academic Press, 1970), pp. 195–249. DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3454(08)60157-6 (ScienceDirect, paywalled). Available: the published chapter as a scanned PDF, 55 pages, read in full (text, footnotes, Figures 1–20 and their captions, references). No data or code exist; every number below is read from the text. Nothing is read off a figure.
2. What the paper hands over
Primary: an argument, built from a review. Tool-using is “the use of an external object as a functional extension of mouth or beak, hand or claw, in the attainment of an immediate goal” (p. 195); nest-building and string-pulling are manipulation of materials, not tool-use. Tool-use is found in species far apart on the phylogenetic scale, so tool-use as such shows nothing about intelligence (the ant-lion that flings sand is no more “gifted” than the dragonfly larva with a hinged jaw, p. 244). It becomes interesting “when the motor patterns available to a given animal for the manipulation of objects can be adapted to new situations” (p. 244). Each animal’s tool-use grows out of a movement it already has: the Egyptian vulture throws stones at ostrich eggs “using exactly the same movements as those seen when it throws a smaller egg at the ground” (p. 203); the banded mongoose, unable to hurl a dummy ostrich egg between its legs, hurls stones at it instead (p. 205). In the chimpanzee, tool-use develops in each individual from manipulative play, trial and error, observation of others and occasional insight (pp. 240–243); a pattern practised out of context “is readily available and may be adapted to new purposes” (p. 241). Only the chimpanzee, apart from man, adapts tool-use to “a rather wide variety of problems”; only man uses a tool to make a tool (pp. 240, 244–245). Gifted individuals and observational learning may make cultures (p. 245).
Secondary: estimates, from Goodall’s own Gombe observations, on the development of termite-fishing (pp. 228–231):
- Adults push five to eight inches of the tool into the hole; withdraw it “after a slight pause”; pick the termites off with their lips. Tools are prepared (leaves stripped, strips pulled from grass blades, a bent end bitten off); several are picked at once; tools are often selected when the nest is as much as 100 yards away and out of sight (Fig. 16: about 60 yards); no chimpanzee was seen to move out of sight of a nest to fetch a new tool; a tool may be poked in two or three times and then discarded “as though it is the tool that is at fault”.
- Infants under two: no tool-use for termites; from nine months they watch their mothers intently.
- Two to three years: tools used in the right context, but “inappropriate material (too short, too thick, etc.) and clumsy technique (the tool was often pulled from a hole with a jerking movement which would have dislodged any insect that had bitten on)”. In 22 bouts (a few seconds to five minutes), two termites caught.
- Three to four years: tools sometimes longer but often too flexible (Fig. 17: “too long, too flexible”); pushed in “only one or two inches”.
- Four years: “a more adult technique, although their tools were usually shorter”; bouts up to 15 minutes against under five for three-year-olds.
- Infants picked up and used tools that adults discarded (p. 243).
Also handed over: the sponge (pp. 232–233, 242). Adults at Gombe drink from hollows by stripping leaves, chewing them briefly (“thus increasing their absorbancy”) and pushing the mass in. A three-and-a-half-year-old, after first dipping his hand, poked in a piece of dry grass “using movements similar to those observed during termite feeding. Each time he put it to his mouth, he chewed the end: eventually, therefore, the stem was a tiny crumpled mass — a minute ‘sponge’” (Fig. 18). Goodall’s gloss (p. 242): “the repetition of such a pattern during infant play may, on occasion, lead to a new tool-using technique”.
Formalised here as an explicit toy (section 12): a passage with bends, termites that bite on and let go, a stem with length, thickness, stiffness, leaves and a tip that wears; water that a plain stem barely lifts and a crumpled one soaks up.
3. The discovery, and its kind
A mechanism made intelligible, with a counterintuitive edge. The intuitive view (in 1970 and now) is that a tool-using animal is a clever animal, and that a tool is a special thing. The paper: a tool is an ordinary movement given a new object, and any animal can have one by evolution; what marks the chimpanzee is that its movements are learned slowly, by playing, trying and watching, and then carried to new problems. The game’s discovery is played in two steps: the player learns termite-fishing the slow way, making exactly the mistakes Goodall recorded at each age; then the movement they learned turns out to drink water.
4. The core narrative
There is food inside the termite mound, but you can’t get your hand in. Your mother pokes a grass stem down the hole, waits, and pulls it out covered in termites. You try. Your stem is too floppy and folds up; the next one is too fat to go in; when one finally goes in, you yank it out so fast that every termite falls off. It takes young chimpanzees years to get this right, and they learn it by trying and by watching their mothers. Then one day there is water in a hole in a tree, too deep for your lips, and you poke a stem in, the same way you fish for termites, and it comes out wet.
5. Who lives in the paper
- The young chimpanzee (two to four years old): chooses a stem, prepares it or not, pushes it in, waits, pulls it out; watches its mother or not; picks up her discarded tool. Could be asked to anticipate: will this stem go round the bend; how slowly is slow enough? The player, in the pick.
- The mother (an adult): selects tools far from the nest, prepares them, fishes at an adult’s depth. Kept as the one the player can watch, and as the measure of an adult’s catch.
- Goodall, the observer: binoculars and a notebook; she records each bout and what age it looks like. Kept as the voice of the notebook (red pencil), not as the player.
- The termites (Macrotermes bellicosus): bite on to whatever comes into their passage. Kept as the mechanism.
- The Egyptian vulture, the banded mongoose, the seriemas, the bald eagle, the sea otter: each has one or two movements that became a tool. Candidate players for concept C; kept on the last page.
- The zoo experimenters (Dekker in Amsterdam with the seriemas, McGinnis with the mongooses, the van Lawicks with plaster eggs at Ngorongoro): set an animal a problem and watch. Candidate experimenter, concept B.
- The low-ranking male with the paraffin cans (p. 210): rose to the top by banging cans in his charging display. Considered (section 14), cut.
6. Precedent
| Game |
Position |
Format |
Feedback device |
Chassis |
| Who Started It? (interface) |
agent at the table, against a counterpart with a hidden motive |
strategic, hidden types, one purse of fourteen pages |
the overprint: two circles in two inks, the lens stitched or torn |
Swiss International Style poster (Austere): poster stock, ink, signal orange, grass green, olive; Archivo; flat lowercase slabs |
| Curie’s Counterfactuals (curie) |
experimenter, with the paper’s instrument held as a skill |
discovery by survey under a budget of panels |
the balance (a spot of light held still), an album that draws itself, the world strip |
ligne claire album, Paris 1898 (Drawn): album white, ink, uranium yellow, clear blue, signal red; Lilita One + Patrick Hand; ink-framed caption boxes |
| Lovelace’s Cards (lovelace) |
builder: hangs cards on the Engine |
construction puzzle against par |
the loom weaving the pattern |
the Engine on pasteboard (Instrument): buff, ink, plum, verdigris, thread red and blue; Abril Fatface + Old Standard TT; punched-card buttons |
What this game does differently.
- Position: the subject. Not a party at a table, not the experimenter, not a builder: the player is the young animal the paper studies, with the skill being learned in their own hand, while the paper’s observer writes them up. I picked my stems sixty yards away, stripped the leaves, pushed one in six inches and drew it out slowly.
- Format: a challenge of mastery against a clock, then one new problem. One afternoon, twelve dips’ worth of daylight, then a hollow with five. Nobody opposes the player, nothing is surveyed, there is no par: the player gets better, visibly, for reasons they can name, and then the skill meets a problem it was not learned for.
- Device: the stem itself, drawn in section, coming out of the mound beaded with termites or bare; and Goodall’s age ruler, on which a red-pencil tick lands after every dip (two years, three, four, adult). No circles, no spot of light, no album of panels, no loom.
- Chassis: graphite on a squared field notebook (Drawn, by the Given). Cream and graphite where Curie had white and flat colour; a typewriter and a pencil hand where Curie had a comic title face and comic lettering; pencil-boxed paper slips where Curie had ink caption boxes; nothing flat, everything shaded with a pencil.
7. The aim and the verdict
The aim (start screen; top of the mound screen; first line of How to play): Fish termites out of the mound with a stem of grass, before your mother moves on.
The yardstick during play is in the aim’s units: a tally of termites eaten, in pencil strokes of five, which grows the moment a stem comes out with termites on it; and the afternoon, twelve small suns across the page, one shaded per dip. Every stem that comes out is visibly a success or a failure at once: termites on it, or none.
The second aim (the hollow, a surprise: not announced on the start screen): Drink the rainwater in the hollow. Your lips can’t reach it. Yardstick: sips, drawn as a mouth-level gauge that fills toward “enough”.
The verdict (the notebook’s last page), three lines composed from what the player did, then the age ruler with every dip ticked on it:
- What you did: “You caught 26 termites this afternoon; your mother, about 70. Your first dips looked like a two-year-old’s (a stick too thick to go in); your last, like an adult’s (a stiff stem, stripped, six inches in, out slowly). You learned it by trying, and by watching your mother once. Then you pushed your stem into the hollow, the way you fish, chewed the end, and drank.”
- What the paper says: “Goodall watched young chimpanzees take two years over what you did in an afternoon. Between two and three: the wrong stems, and a jerk that shakes the termites off; two termites in twenty-two tries. At three, stems too long and too floppy, in an inch or two. At four, an adult’s way, with a shorter tool. A three-and-a-half-year-old made the first sponge she saw from a stem of dry grass, by chewing it each time he sucked it.”
- What it means: “A tool on its own is nothing clever: a vulture smashes ostrich eggs with stones, but it throws them with the throw it uses on small eggs, and that is all it does. What Goodall found remarkable is a movement learned slowly, by playing, trying and watching, then carried to a new problem. No animal but us does that for as many problems as the chimpanzee.”
No score number; the tally is a count of what was eaten, and the verdict says what it means in words.
8. Three concepts
A. Goodall’s Long Grass (subject: a young chimpanzee; a challenge of mastery against a clock, then a new problem).
- Controls: in the long grass, tap a stem to hold it (it is drawn held out over a ruler, drooping as much as it really does), TAKE IT (three at most), STRIP THE LEAVES. At the mound: one gesture, a vertical drag on the section drawing (down pushes the stem in, letting go leaves it there, up draws it out); BITE OFF THE END; WATCH YOUR MOTHER; PICK ANOTHER STEM NEARBY. At the hollow: the same drag, CHEW THE END, PICK SOME LEAVES.
- Deliberation: which stems to carry when the hole cannot be seen (long or short, thin or thick, floppy or stiff, leafy or bare); how deep, how long to wait, how slowly to pull; whether to spend a dip watching her or trying; bite the bent end off or switch; and at the hollow, what on earth to do.
- After: the stem moving in the passage, folding at a bend or not, stopping or going on; termites arriving and clinging; termites falling off during a fast pull; the count; the typed line; the red-pencil tick on Goodall’s ruler.
- Moment: the first slow pull of a stiff stem six inches in, after a fast one that shook them all off: the stem comes up beaded with termites. Then the hollow, where nothing has been explained, and the termite stem comes out wet.
- Fun: agency (the drag is the technique; a slow hand is rewarded visibly), mastery (dip 8 is better than dip 2 for reasons the player can name: firm, deep, slow), discovery (the notebook names the age each mistake belongs to; the stem drinks), anticipation (will it go round the bend?).
- Second play: the other way of learning (watch first and copy; or never watch); another bunch of grass with different stems; a sponge from leaves instead of the stem, or the stem instead of leaves.
B. The Plaster Egg (experimenter: the zoo tester; discovery).
- Controls: five animals in turn (Egyptian vulture, seriema, banded mongoose, bald eagle, chimpanzee), one plaster ostrich egg; the player chooses what to put beside it (a stone, an anvil rock, a stick, a small egg, nothing) and runs three tests per animal, predicting before each whether the animal will use a tool.
- Deliberation: which object will this animal use, given what it does with food already?
- Moment: the mongoose tries to hurl the giant egg backwards between its legs (Fig. 4), fails, and then hurls a stone at it the same way (Fig. 5).
- Fun: discovery, anticipation. Second play: little; the animals answer the same way.
- Why it loses: the player watches more than acts, and the core loop is a prediction; it is Curie’s position (experimenter) and close to Curie’s format (a survey under a budget); the paper’s experiments are tiny (two seriemas, two mongooses, four tests), so most outcomes would be ours.
C. The Throw (agent, of a strange kind: the player is a movement; the reckless one).
- Controls: the player is the head-flick an Egyptian vulture uses to smash a small egg on the ground, drawn as a pencil arc. It cannot change its shape. Drag an object into it and release toward a target. It passes from body to body: the vulture, the mongoose’s backward hurl, the bald eagle’s beak-throw (Fig. 3), the chimpanzee’s threat gesture (Fig. 13).
- Deliberation: in each body, the problem the movement cannot solve with its usual object, and what else it could carry.
- Moment: the vulture faces an ostrich egg too big to lift and the throw has nothing to throw, until the player drags a stone into the arc. Then the chimpanzee, threatening a baboon with a banana in hand: let go mid-gesture and the banana flies (p. 222).
- Fun: discovery, a little agency. Second play: none to speak of.
- Why it is reckless: the protagonist is an abstraction with no body and no wants; almost nothing on screen can be explained in words without giving the answer; and after the first stone every body is the same trick.
Also considered and dropped: The Cans (agent: the low-ranking male who bangs paraffin cans to the top, p. 210). A strategic display game against higher-ranking males. One anecdote, a payoff entirely ours, and a story about status, not tools.
9. The first five minutes
A (the pick). 0:00. A cream page ruled in faint squares. A binocular view, two overlapping circles, and inside it a pencil drawing of an old female chimpanzee at a termite mound with a grass stem between finger and thumb. Typed: GOODALL’S LONG GRASS. “Gombe Stream, Tanzania. The termite season.” The aim on its own line: Fish termites out of the mound with a stem of grass, before your mother moves on. INTO THE LONG GRASS.
0:15. The long grass, drawn in pencil, swaying. Eight stems stand out darker. Typed: “Sixty yards from the mound: you can’t see the hole from here. Take up to three stems.” I touch the longest: it is lifted into a box marked in your hand, held out over a ruler: thirteen inches, thin, and it droops at the far end like a wet noodle. I touch a thick stick: eleven inches, stiff, fat. A leafy twig: ten inches, thin, stiff, leaves on it. A short twig, four inches. I think: long reaches further. I take the long grass blade, the thick stick and the leafy twig. WALK TO THE MOUND.
0:50. The mound, drawn as a section on the squared page: the hole at the top, a passage curving down past two bends to a chamber where termites wait, a ruler of inches beside it. My mother is a small figure at her own hole on the right. Twelve suns across the top; my tally, empty. “Drag down to push your stem in. Let go to leave it in. Drag up to pull it out. Termites bite on to whatever comes into their passage.” I drag: the grass blade goes in, reaches the first bend at an inch and a half, and folds up above the hole. I drag harder; it folds more. I let go, wait, pull. “In 1½ inches: it folded at the first bend. No termites.” Red pencil, in Goodall’s hand, a tick on her ruler at 3 yrs: “too long, too flexible: in only an inch or two (Fig. 17)”. Hm.
1:30. The thick stick: it stops at the rim. “Too thick for the hole. No termites.” Tick at 2 yrs: “the wrong material”. I frown. 1:45. The leafy twig: the leaves catch on the rim. STRIP THE LEAVES (the box shows it bare before I press). It slides past the first bend, the second, down into the chamber: six and a half inches. I let go; small grey termites gather and cling to it. I pull fast. They fly off as it comes up; two are left. “Out fast: five shaken off. 2 termites.” Tick at 2 yrs: “a jerk, which would dislodge any insect that had bitten on”. I see what I did.
2:20. Same twig, slowly, my thumb crawling up the glass. It comes out beaded. “In 6½ inches, a pause, out slowly. 7 termites.” Tick at adult: “five to eight inches; out smoothly”. I grin. 2:40. Next dip, it folds at the first bend. “The end is bent.” BITE OFF THE END (the box shows it an inch shorter). It goes in again. 3:00. WATCH YOUR MOTHER: the binocular view, her stem coming out slowly; her section: seven inches, nine termites. “She picked hers in the long grass, before she came.” She drops it beside her, bent at the end. PICK UP HER STEM. 3:20 to 4:00. Five more dips, mostly adult ticks, one jerk when I hurry. The last sun is shaded: “Your mother gets up and moves off.” 31 termites; hers, about 70.
4:05. A tree trunk in section, a hollow with rainwater three inches down. New aim: Drink the rainwater in the hollow. Your lips can’t reach it. Five suns; a gauge for sips. Nothing tells me what to do. I try my hand: it won’t go in past the knuckles. I take my twig and do what my thumb now does without thinking: push, wait, pull. It comes out wet: one sip. Again: two sips, the end a little chewed. CHEW THE END: the box shows a crumpled tip. Four sips. 4:50. PICK SOME LEAVES, CHEW THEM: a wad; nine sips. Enough. Red pencil: “A 3½-year-old did this with a stem of dry grass: a minute sponge (Fig. 18).” 5:10. The last page.
C (the runner-up, and the reckless one). 0:00. A pencil arc on cream, and a line: “You are a throw: the flick of the head an Egyptian vulture uses to smash an egg on the ground. You can’t change your shape; you can change what you hold.” 0:15. A small egg; I drag it into the arc and let go; it smashes. 0:30. An ostrich egg, too big for the arc. I drag it: it won’t lift. Pebbles lie about. I drag one into the arc and let go at the egg; on the fourth stone it cracks. Fig. 2, in pencil. A grin, once. 1:20. The arc turns into a mongoose’s backward hurl between its legs. The giant egg won’t go between them (Fig. 4); a stone will. The same grin, smaller. 2:00. The bald eagle’s beak, a cricket two feet away: drag a stone, let go. 2:40. A chimpanzee threatening a baboon, a banana in hand: the arm swings; I let go and the banana flies at the baboon. Is that the point? 3:30. I have done one trick five times. “And I don’t know what I’m supposed to feel” from the eagle onward: the paper’s thesis is there in one gesture, but after the first stone the player has nothing to weigh.
10. The pick, and why
A, Goodall’s Long Grass. The player is inside the paper at the place Goodall’s own data are richest: the termite mound, where she recorded what a young chimpanzee gets wrong at each age. Every mistake the paper lists (too short, too thick, too flexible, in only an inch or two, pulled out with a jerk) is a move a stranger will make on their own, because each looks sensible (long reaches further; fat is strong; fast is efficient), and the notebook names the age each one belongs to. The deliberation is real twice over: what to carry when the hole cannot be seen, and how to move the thumb. The discovery lands inside three minutes (the slow pull), and the thesis inside five (the termite movement drinks). The sentence afterwards has no “guess”: I picked three stems sixty yards away, stripped one, pushed it in six inches and drew it out slowly; then I chewed it into a sponge. Originality: no game in the table has made the player an animal learning a skill in its body, and none has scored a move on the paper’s own developmental scale.
Author test. The colleague who sent the paper knows that chimpanzees fish for termites; he does not know, until his thumb tells him, how easy it is to pull too fast, or that a long grass blade is a three-year-old’s mistake. A primatologist would recognise Fig. 16 (the tool picked sixty yards away), Fig. 17 (the floppy stem), Fig. 18 (the sponge), the bitten-off end, the discarded tool an infant picks up, and the five-to-eight inches. Goodall’s notebook as the voice that ticks the player’s age is the kind of joke the author would enjoy.
Runner-up: C, The Throw. Switch if the author wants the paper’s breadth (birds, mongooses, otters, apes) played rather than read, in a ninety-second toy, and accepts that the player’s choice is thin after the first stone.
What the reckless concept would have given. The paper’s thesis felt as one movement finding new objects, across species, without a word. Kept from it: the hollow, where the movement the player has just learned is carried, unchanged, to a new problem; and the vulture, the mongoose and the eagle on the last page, each with the one throw that became its tool. Given up: playing the other species.
11. The shape (as rebuilt in revision 3)
One game in two places, about five minutes, and one drawing for each. At the mound: six suns (twelve until revision 4); each dip costs one. The whole afternoon is one pencil plate: the long grass on the left with five stems standing in it, the mound cut open in the middle with your hole, your mother at her own hole on the right, fishing every sun in the picture. You hold one stem at a time: touch a stem in the grass and it comes into your hand, drawn as itself; whatever you held goes on the heap at the foot of the mound, and the grass grows back, so the five kinds (a blade, a stem, a leafy twig, a stick, and one more) are always there to choose from. Then the hollow (five suns), the last page, How to play, About. No presets: the paper’s regimes are ages, and the player passes through them by their own hand. Ordered for the player: the mound first, because the movement has to be learned before it can be carried; the hollow unannounced. Score: none; the tally of termites, the sips, the heap and the ticks on Goodall’s ruler are the yardstick. The game ends once; ANOTHER AFTERNOON begins a new one with new grass.
12. Controls, mechanism, feedback, moment
- Controls. Mound: touch a stem standing in the grass to take it (one in hand at a time; the other goes on the heap); one gesture on the plate: press and hold, and the stem goes into the hole by itself at a grown-up’s push and waits there while the termites climb on; let go, and it comes out, as a snatch if you let go within half a second of its arriving and gently otherwise (revision 6); if a stem is in the hole and another is touched, the game draws the first out at a slow pull and switches; two pencil tags on the plate, present only when they apply, are touches: leaves on it: touch to strip them, bent end: touch to bite it off; your mother’s thrown-down stem lies between the holes with her stem: touch to take. Watching her costs nothing: she fishes in the picture after every sun. Hollow: press and what you hold goes in, let go and it comes out (speed is nothing to water); slips to hold the stem, your hand or the leaves; CHEW THE END; PICK SOME LEAVES. Ants’ nest (revision 6): the same press and hold: the stick goes in, the ants run up it, let go before they reach your fingers; the clump is there to take a longer stick.
- Mechanism (formalised from the argument; numbers in CONFIG). The passage: entrance a quarter inch wide (a thick stick stops at the rim; unstripped leaves catch there), a bend at 1½ inches, a second at 4 inches, termites from 3 inches down to the end at 8. A stem has a length, a thickness, a stiffness (floppy, springy, stiff), leaves or none, and a tip that wears. It goes in as far as the finger pushes, unless stopped: a floppy stem (or a bent tip) folds at the first bend, a springy one at the second; the grip uses 1½ inches, so a four-inch twig reaches 2½. Termites bite on to the part of the stem below 3 inches at a rate per inch, gathering over a second or two after the stem stops moving. Each termite has a grip; a termite lets go when the stem moves faster than its grip, so a slow pull keeps them all and a flick keeps none. Every dip past the first bend wears the tip; three dips and it is bent. The mother fishes an adult’s dip every sun. Hollow: the water stands 3 inches down; a hand reaches 1½ inches; a plain stem lifts a sip, a crumpled end more, a chewed wad of leaves most; each suck crumples a grass end a little more, as the paper says; twelve sips is enough. Each dip is classed on Goodall’s scale by what happened: the wrong material (too thick, leaves on, too short) or a jerk: two years; a floppy stem in an inch or two: three; smooth and in three to five inches, or a short tool: four; smooth and in five to eight, with a full-length stem: adult.
- Feedback. The stem drawn in the passage moving with the thumb, folding where it folds; termites appearing along it and clinging; termites dropping as it comes up too fast; the eat (termites picked off the stem one by one into the tally); the result in the game’s voice (typed); then Goodall’s line in red pencil with a tick on her age ruler. At the hollow: the stem coming out dark with water, the drops, the gauge.
- Moment. The slow pull after the fast one. Then the hollow, with nothing explained.
13. The look
Register: the paper’s own figures (Drawn family: a hand-drawn notebook and the naturalist’s “drawing from photo”). It comes from the Given and from the paper itself, whose figures are either pencil-and-ink drawings traced from photographs (Figs. 1, 4, 13: “Drawing from photo by…”) or grainy photographs of chimpanzees in long grass at Gombe (Figs. 7–20). The game draws everything as such a tracing: soft graphite contour, short hatch strokes for fur and shade, no fills, no flat colour. The notebook is the page everything sits on: squared, cream, with typed entries and a pencil hand in the margin, the way field notes were kept and typed up.
- Palette: notebook cream
#F1EBDC (the page); graphite #2E2F31 (every line, the text, the primary slip), with two lighter pressures of the same pencil, #6F6E6B (secondary lines, captions) and #B3AEA3 (hatching, the grass behind); squared-rule blue #CAD5D9 (the faint grid only); red pencil #A9452F (Goodall’s hand only).
- Type: Courier Prime (Alan Dague-Greene, SIL OFL), the typewriter in which field notes were typed up, for the game’s voice, labels, buttons and the title, regular and bold; Kalam (Indian Type Foundry, SIL OFL), a light pencil hand, for Goodall’s red-pencil lines and the ruler’s age marks. Both embedded as data.
- Buttons: paper slips: a typed label in capitals inside a pencil-ruled box (1.5 px graphite, corners barely rounded, the line roughened by an SVG pencil filter where the browser allows it, clean where it does not), cream on cream; the primary action is a slip shaded solid with graphite and typed in cream. No shadows, no colour.
- The one visual rule: graphite for everything that happens; red pencil for Goodall’s hand and nothing else. The player’s dips, stems, termites and water are graphite; the paper’s word on them (the age, the figure number, the five-to-eight inches) arrives afterwards in red, in the margin and on the ruler.
- The plate at 380 px (revision 3): the aim (two lines, 13 px) with ? at the right; a strip with six suns and the tally (strokes of five up to twenty, then the number); the plate, 348 × 285 on the squared page: pale grass strokes and five stems standing in the long grass at the left, each drawn as itself (a blade wide and floppy with a midrib, a grass stem with nodes and a seed head, a leafy twig with alternate leaves, a bark-textured stick with a knot, a twig with buds) at 8 px to the inch, each a touch target; the ground line; the mound’s hump with two holes; your passage drawn as a double pencil line through two bends to the chamber, inches on its right; her passage on the right, plainer; termites waiting below three inches in both; your stem rising from your hole into a chimpanzee’s hand at the upper left, foreshortened so the hand stays on the page and moves as the stem goes in; her stem and hand from the upper right, mirrored; the heap of dropped stems at the foot of the mound; her thrown-down stem between the holes when there is one; a pencil note in the lower left with a dotted leader the moment something stops the stem; the drag hint in the lower left until the first dip is completed; directly under the plate the result line typed, Goodall’s line in red pencil, her ruler, then the figure caption. One visual rule as before: graphite for everything that happens, red pencil for Goodall’s hand only.
- The long grass is on the plate (above); there is no separate grass screen.
- The hollow at 380 px: the same layout as the mound, with a tree trunk in section and the water surface drawn as a few level pencil strokes; a gauge of sips (a vertical pencil tube at the right, filling with graphite) in place of the tally.
- Last page: the heading typed; the three verdict lines; Goodall’s ruler at full width with every dip ticked and numbered; the two tallies (yours, hers) in strokes of five; three small pencil drawings in the paper’s manner, each with a typed caption in the paper’s style (FIG. 1. Egyptian vulture about to throw a stone at an ostrich egg. FIG. 2. Banded mongoose hurling a stone between its legs. FIG. 3. Young chimpanzee with a grass stem, termite season); ANOTHER AFTERNOON, How to play, About.
14. What is cut
- Weapons and displays (half the paper): branch-waving, dropping, aimed throwing at baboons (one hit in nine throws the first year, four in thirty-two the next), clubbing, the paraffin cans. Named in one line on About; the cans considered as a concept and dropped (section 8).
- The other species played. Birds and non-primate mammals appear on the last page, as drawings with captions, and on About. The reckless concept would have played them.
- Captivity and the laboratory (Köhler’s sticks and boxes, Khroustov’s hand axe): one line on the last page (“only we use a tool to make a tool”) and on About.
- The definition of a tool (tool against material, the shrike’s thorn, the gull’s rock). On About, in a paragraph.
- Sniffing the stem’s end (p. 232), honey, ants, wiping with leaves, the stick that knocked a banana from a hand. Cut for length; the last is the paper’s only case of insight in the wild, and named on About.
- Kortlandt’s “dehumanization” hypothesis and Goodall’s reply. On About, in a sentence.
- Cultures and the gifted individual (the paper’s last paragraph). The last page’s closing line, read, not played.
15. Divergences
- The clock. An afternoon of six dips (twelve until revision 4) stands for the two years (about two to four) over which Goodall’s infants learned; termite seasons last three or four months a year. Reason: the player has to pass through the ages by their own hand in a few minutes.
- The passage, the termites and the stem are ours. Bends, widths, depths of the chamber, the rate at which termites bite on, their grip, the wear of the tip, the length the fingers take up: chosen so that the paper’s mistakes fail for the paper’s reasons and the adult technique (five to eight inches, a slight pause, a smooth withdrawal) succeeds. The paper gives the depths, the mistakes and the preparations, not the mechanics.
- The section view. A chimpanzee feels the passage; it does not see it. The player sees in pencil what the hand would feel. Declared on About.
- The mother’s catch per dip and the termites per inch are ours. The paper gives no adult rates; the infants’ two in twenty-two bouts is the one count, and the toy reproduces it (section 17).
- The age a dip is given is our mapping of Goodall’s descriptions to what happened in the dip; the ages themselves and their descriptions are hers.
- The hollow. Two of the paper’s drinking techniques, the adult’s chewed leaves and the infant’s chewed stem, with sips, absorbencies and the threshold for “enough” ours. The infant who invented the stem sponge was three and a half; the game does not say how old the player is.
- One mound, one hole, one hollow. The paper’s male who carried one tool half a mile past nests that were none of them ready is cut.
- The grass beside the mound, one stem at a time, and the mother in the picture (revision 3). The paper’s adults choose tools as much as a hundred yards away, out of sight of the nest, and carry several; the game puts the grass beside the mound, offers one of each kind every round, and lets you hold one stem at a time, so that the choice of stem is the whole of each round. Watching the mother costs nothing: she fishes at her own hole in the picture after every sun, and infants, the paper says, watch intently. Declared on About.
16. Mechanism kind and claim boundaries
Kind: a toy, calibrated to the paper’s few numbers. The paper hands over an argument and field descriptions, not a model. The game formalises the termite-fishing descriptions as a passage with two bends and a chamber, termites that bite on over a second or two and let go above a grip speed, and stems with a length, thickness, stiffness, leaves and a tip that wears; and the sponge as sips per dip by what is pushed in. It is calibrated to: the adults’ five to eight inches; the three-to-four-year-olds’ one or two inches with too-flexible tools; the two termites in twenty-two bouts of the two-to-three-year-olds; the order of the ages; and the paper’s account of a chewed end soaking up more.
- Demonstrates: under its own assumptions, that the infants’ mistakes Goodall lists fail for her reasons, and the adult technique succeeds; that the movement learned at the mound drinks at the hollow once the end is crumpled.
- Assumes: the inside of the mound, the termites’ bite and grip, the wear of a tip, the stems’ lengths, the clock (twelve dips for two years), our mapping of a dip to an age, the sips. The player sees the passage; a chimpanzee feels it.
- The paper establishes: the observed ages, mistakes, depths, the two in twenty-two, the preparations, the grass and leaf sponges, at one site in the 1960s; its developmental account (play, trial and error, observation, insight) and the cultural point are reasoned from observation, not tested.
Which discoveries come from the paper and which from the rules. (1) The infants’ mistakes catch nothing and the adult way catches several: from the paper (each failure is one Goodall names, with her depths); the size of the catch is ours. (2) A slow pull keeps the termites, a jerk loses them: from the paper (“a jerking movement which would have dislodged any insect that had bitten on”); the grip speeds are ours. (3) Choosing out of sight, carrying spares, biting a bent end, picking up her stem: the behaviours are the paper’s; that they pay (in termites per afternoon) follows from our clock and wear, and the game presents them as what chimpanzees do, not as findings. (4) Watching once pays; watching four times costs more: a design consequence of the clock, not a claim of the paper, which says only that infants watch and that observational learning “might also play a role”. The verdict reports how the player learned, and does not say which way is better. (5) The termite movement drinks: the paper’s infant did exactly this; the sips are ours.
17. Calibration plan and result
calibration.js runs the mechanism headless, through the same dipStep the browser drives, with a simulated finger (push at 6 inches per second, a pause, a pull at a chosen speed):
- A. The long grass over 1000 afternoons: eight stems, always a stiff grass stem and a leafy twig (the floor), lengths in range, replayable by number.
- B. The paper’s numbers: grown-up technique goes in 5–8 inches (result 7.0–8.0); a floppy stem goes in 1–2 inches (1.5); an infant of 2–3 (any stem, unprepared, a jerk of 10 to 30 inches per second, one dip per bout) catches about two in twenty-two (result 2.4 per 22, over 22,000 bouts; tolerance 0.7–5); the mother’s dips are all 5–8 inches and classed grown-up; catch per dip rises with the ages (2–3: 0.08, 3–4: 0.33, 4: 2.2, grown-up: 7.9); each age’s way of fishing is classed at its age by the notebook (2–3: 96 %, 3–4: 67 %, 4: 99 %, grown-up: 100 %); at the hollow, hand alone (5 sips) and fresh leaves (10) fall short, the infant’s sucked stem (14), a chewed stem (15) and chewed leaves (12) drink their fill (12).
- C. Playing it in numbers (section 18).
- D. Robustness: each of our choices varied one at a time (first bend at 1 or 2 inches; second bend at 3½ or 5; chamber from 2 or 4 inches; 1.2 or 2.4 termites per inch; bite-on time 0.5 or 1.5 seconds; grips 12–28 or 24–48 inches per second). In every variant the grown-up way catches between 5 and 11 per dip, a jerk catches none, a floppy stem and a stick catch none, and the floppy stem still goes in one or two inches. The central discovery does not rest on the particular numbers.
- E. Rules: costs of a dip, a watch and a fetch; a touch under a fifth of an inch is free; termites fill to the cap; a tip bends after three dips and biting restores it; her thrown stem can be picked up; determinism; the verdict has words and no decimals; previews change nothing.
Result: 26 checks, 26 passed (calibration-result.txt).
18. Playing it in numbers (build.md §3)
300 afternoons per strategy, through the real mechanism; termites eaten in the afternoon, and the age of the last dip.
| Strategy |
Termites (mean; min–max) |
Last dip |
| Long is best (three longest, no preparation, slow) |
5 (0–32) |
3–4 (30 %) |
| Fast hands (good stems, pulled at a flick) |
0 |
2–3 |
| Trial and error (mixed kit; slows after a jerk, drops what folds) |
23 (0–28) |
grown-up (81 %) |
| Copy your mother (watch once, then as she does) |
40 |
grown-up |
| Watcher (watch four times first) |
16 |
grown-up |
| Never bites a bent end |
24 |
3–4 |
| Four-year-old (shorter or springier tools) |
8 (6–26) |
4 |
| Best possible (never watches) |
48 |
grown-up |
| Her, every afternoon |
about 39 |
grown-up |
(Six-sun afternoons, from revision 4; the harness still carries three stems and pays a sun to watch, as the first build did.) The decisions matter (best against long-is-best or fast hands: nine times and more); learning by trying gets near half of the way in six suns; one look at her pays, four cost; biting a bent end is worth twenty-four termites. No single rule wins: the long stem, the fast hand and the short tool each fail for a different reason, which is the paper’s list of mistakes. A player who fishes perfectly from the first dip out-fishes the mother (she never goes the whole eight inches); a real first-timer, who spends dips learning, does not. At the hollow, after any afternoon, a grass stem sucked five times or chewed first drinks its fill; a hand or a twig does not.
19. Build log
- Mechanism first (
mechanism.js, headless; calibration.js, 26 checks). The first strategy table had the “four-year-old” heuristic picking the short twig, which catches nothing; it was a mis-specified heuristic, not a property of the toy, and was corrected to the shorter and springier tools a four-year-old uses. The first mother fished shallower (5½–7½ inches) than a player pushing to the bottom, so a perfect player out-fished her by a quarter; her depth was moved to 6–8 inches, inside the paper’s five to eight.
- Loop on placeholders (
loop.js, loop-log.txt): a scripted first-timer (a floppy blade, a stick, an unstripped leafy twig, a fast pull, a slow one, one look at the mother, a bitten end, her stem; at the hollow the hand, the blade, a chew). Every action printed a visible change and a plain statement of what happened; the red line names an age every time.
- Skin. Graphite on a squared cream page, drawn with SVG hatching through a pencil-grain filter; the old female at the mound drawn once for the cover in a binocular frame and reused, small, on the last page beside an Egyptian vulture with a stone. The section of the mound is drawn to the mechanism’s own inches (21 pixels to the inch), with the hand and forearm coming in from the upper left and the stem bowing above the hole when it is pushed against a block.
- The first browser session failed for a good reason. With the stem’s buttons under the drawing, every preparation scrolled the drawing off a phone screen, and the scripted drag landed on the text instead. The play screen was reordered: what is in your hand, and what you can do to it, above the drawing; the result, Goodall’s line and her ruler directly under it; watching her and fetching a stem at the bottom.
- A dead zone in the drag. Pushing a blocked stem further stored the excess, so pulling back did nothing for up to three inches of finger travel. The drag now re-anchors once the bow above the hole reaches an inch and a half: pulling back answers at once.
- Words. “The end is bent now” was said after every dip with a bent stem; it is now said only when it bends. Picking up her stem with full hands drops the one you hold; the button now says so before you press it.
- The hollow gave the answer away. Goodall’s note after the first wet grass stem described the chewed sponge before the player had made it. It now says only that an infant poked grass in the way he fished for termites; the sponge is named once the end has crumpled. The game’s own line (“sucking it chews the end a little”) is the paper’s mechanism, and is the only nudge.
- The last page. The headline now carries the discovery as well as the player’s result (“…fished like a grown-up chimpanzee, which took the infants Goodall watched about two years; then you made a sponge out of a termite stem”). The first vulture looked like a pigeon; it was redrawn upright with a long beak, a ragged nape and dark flight feathers. The thing in your hand was lost from the hand box once the hollow ended; fixed in the mechanism.
- Full browser session (
session-test.js, session-log.txt, 380 × 780, real-time drags): Game A (afternoon 7) a first-timer’s afternoon with every mistake, How to play opened with a stem resting in the passage and closed back to it, one look at the mother, her stem picked up, two bitten ends, 48 termites; the hollow by hand, stem, chewed stem and chewed leaves; the last page; About and back. Game B (a new afternoon) watched first and copied her: 84 termites, a stem sponge. Game C (the same long grass again, same page number, same grass confirmed) a careless afternoon with a floppy blade: no termites, and the stem sponge at the hollow anyway. No errors, no horizontal scroll at 380 px. The last page was re-shot after its final spacing change.
- Self-review from the screenshots. The aim is on the cover in one sentence, after three lines saying what the hands will do. The top of the last page states the result and the discovery in one sentence. On the mound, the drawing labels the hole, the bends, the inches and where the termites wait, the instruction sits across its top until the first dip, and every dip is followed by a typed statement of what happened and then Goodall’s line; the preparation buttons show their result in the hand box while touched. The hollow says only what the place is and how to drag; what to do there is the player’s. It looks like no game in the table: no flat colour, no comic, no poster; graphite on squared cream with a typewriter and a pencil hand.
- Length: about five to six minutes for a first afternoon, by the scripted sessions; an estimate until a person has played it.
- Revision 1 (3 Nov, after the first human play: no termites eaten). Two things in the numbers stopped a player. The termites’ grip (5–16 inches per second) was set for a simulated finger, not a hand: at 21 pixels to the inch a full catch needed a pull under about 100 px/s, and a person’s deliberate “slow” drag is 200–400 px/s, a trackpad’s faster, so every natural pull read as the infants’ jerk. Grips are now 18–36 in/s: a deliberate drag (under ~380 px/s) keeps every termite, a flick (over ~800 px/s) none; the infant’s jerk in the calibration is 25–75 in/s and the paper’s two in twenty-two still comes out (3.1). And a kit of blades and a stick could leave a player with nothing that reached the chamber all afternoon, since the stems within reach by the mound were weighted toward blades: one of the three is now always a thin, stiff stem, so a poor kit can be mended for one sun. Strategy table unchanged to the decimal for slow hands; calibration 26 of 26; the scripted session re-run.
- Revision 1b (3 Nov, after his second play: “no option to just eat”). The one control that is the game, the drag on the section drawing, sat below the fold on a laptop under the stem’s buttons, and eating has no button (it happens when the stem comes out), so a player pressed buttons and never fished. Now: a bold typed line between the hand box and the drawing, shown until the first dip in each place, says to press on the drawing and drag the stem down, let go, drag up, and that what comes out is eaten (“there is no button for it: the drag is the fishing”); the drag hint on the drawing stays until a dip is completed rather than vanishing at the first touch; after watching the mother with no dip yet, the result line ends “Now you: drag your stem down into the hole in the drawing.”; the opening line at the mound says drag, not push.
- Revision 1c (3 Nov, after his third play: “I cannot easily switch to one of the other stems”). While a stem was in the hole (left there, or folded), a touch on another slot was silently ignored until the stem had been dragged out. Now a touch on another stem draws the one in the hole out at a slow pull (nothing on it is lost, the dip counts as the dip it was) and then takes the one touched; the slot label says so while a stem is in (“touch another: this one comes out first”). A touch that never entered the hole costs nothing and switches at once.
- Revision 3 (3 Nov, “make it beautiful and human”). After four plays he found the apparatus (three slots, a ruler strip, fetch, switch) more than the paper asked for, the stems all alike (“asparagus”), and no progression from round to round. Rebuilt around one drawing and one stem at a time: the long grass with five standing stems, the mound with your hole and hers, your mother fishing in the picture every sun, the heap of dropped stems growing at the mound’s foot, your stem drawn as itself in the grass, in your hand and in the passage (one
stemArt for all three), her thrown-down stem touchable, leaves and bent ends touched on the plate instead of buttons, no slots, no fetch, no watch button. Mechanism: beginMound, pickFromGrass (the clump grows back by kind), dropHeld; pickUpHers heaps the stem in hand; the verdict’s learning line now says she fished beside you and how many stems you tried; CARRY, the long-grass phase and the calibration harness unchanged (calibration 26 of 26). The grass screen, hand box, slots and the watch/fetch buttons are gone from the template; build.py rebuilds the HTML from template.html, which earlier revisions had bypassed. Measured: phone 380 × 780, plate 232–518 with the result at 524; laptop 1280 × 700, plate 106–440, result 446, red line 491. Scripted session rewritten for the new flow (three afternoons, no errors, no horizontal scroll). Kept from the paper’s grass: the kinds, lengths, and the floor of one of each.
- Revision 4 (3 Nov). Twelve rounds felt too many to him; the afternoon is six suns. Consequences in the numbers: her stem bends and is thrown down once (at the third sun); a player’s stem bends once; trial and error now gets about half of the best (23 of 48), so the calibration’s check reads “near half” (0.4) instead of “most of the way” (0.5); every other check unchanged, 26 of 26.
- Revision 5 (4 Nov, “still very complicated: I also have to move the stem back; the big stems all look alike”). Two gestures became one: pressing on the mound sends the stem in by itself (6 in/s, the push the mother uses) until something stops it, and it waits; sliding up draws it out at the finger’s speed, with the last inch finished by the game so a pull never stalls at the rim; lifting without sliding leaves it in. At the hollow, press and let go is the whole dip. The held stem now lies long across the sky from the hand at the left edge to the hole (186 px drawn of its real length), so a blade sags, a stick is thick with bark and a knot, a leafy twig carries its leaves and a grass stem its nodes and seed head, where before all four were a short line into a hand. Help and hints updated; scripted session re-run clean (three afternoons); mechanism unchanged.
- Revision 6 (4 Nov, “skip the slide; nothing changes from one afternoon to the next; more help; words for a switched-on eight-year-old”). Four things. One press: press and hold, the stem goes in by itself and waits; let go and it comes out, as a snatch if released within half a second of arriving (the mechanism then pulls at 1.4 × the strongest termite’s grip) and gently otherwise; the paper’s two infant mistakes, no pause and the jerk, are now one thing the hand does. At the hollow, press and let go. Afternoons that differ (
dealAfternoon): afternoon 1 is the canonical mound with the mother present and the hollow after; afternoon 2 a different mound (bends at 1 and 3½, chamber from 4, end at 7), no stiff grass stem in the clump, the mother gone ahead, and the driver ants after; later afternoons dealt from the page number within ranges (bends 1–2 and 3½–5, chamber 3–5, end 6–8; the clump always a blade, a stick and three more with at least one of stem or leafy twig; the mother away with chance 0.4; water and ants alternating). The passage’s drawing, inch marks, the mother’s depth and the waiting termites follow the numbers. The driver ants: a second place for the carried movement (startAntDip, antStep): the stick goes 4 inches into the nest; after a second the ants run up it at 0.9 in/s and climb on at 3 a second; let go and you eat what climbed on; if the front reaches your fingers (the stick’s length outside the nest, so a long stick buys time) you are bitten and eat nothing; a floppy blade folds and catches none; 30 ants is a meal, five suns. About says the ants are in the paper by a line and the ant-dipping detail is from later Gombe work. Help and words: a bold “now” line under the plate says what to do at every state (coach); the on-plate hints say press and hold; every result line, Goodall’s red lines, the verdict and the last page were rewritten in short plain sentences (“It went in eight inches, right to the bottom. You waited. You pulled it out gently. Eight termites!”); How to play rewritten for a child; the cover says it is a one-finger game. Calibration 26 of 26 (unchanged canonical mound; a bendy stem folding at the second bend is now classed with the three-year-olds). Scripted session rewritten: two afternoons (mound and hollow; a different mound, alone, the ants) and a careless replay, no errors.
Renamed (11 November 2026)
Renamed from Goodall’s Long Grass to Go Fishing with Goodall, at the author’s decision to let some titles say what the player does while keeping the name. The game file is go-fishing-with-goodall.html; a one-line page at goodalls-long-grass.html sends old links to it. Nothing in the mechanism changed.