Mine: the game carries Steffen’s signature and counter. Ideas given: “Instrument register, like The Olive: dark sky, the eyepiece and the spectrograph as the instruments, animated and fancy. Otherwise free.” This fixes the register family (Instrument) and the two instruments the player holds; it overrides the precedent rule only in that The Olive (the first game in the table, not one of the last three) was also Instrument. The last three were Loud, Drawn and Austere, so the rule is met anyway. Palette, type, buttons and the visual rule are chosen to differ from The Olive’s green phosphor as well.
Edwin Hubble, “A relation between distance and radial velocity among extra-galactic nebulae”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 15 (1929): 168–173. doi:10.1073/pnas.15.3.168. Open access at pnas.org. Only the PDF was available: a scan with an OCR layer. The two tables were transcribed by hand from the scan and checked against the well-known transcriptions of this paper (Table 1’s 24 nebulae, Table 2’s 22); the OCR had mangled several digits (e.g. “7331 19.0 1.1 + 500” came through intact, “N.G.C. 6822” came through as “N. G. C. 6822 .. 0.214 - 130” intact; the headers were garbled). Figure 1 is the famous plot; its points are Table 1’s distances against velocities corrected for solar motion.
Primary: an estimate. Table 1: 24 nebulae with a distance r (millions of parsecs) and a measured radial velocity v (km/s), plus, for 14 of them, the photographic magnitude of their brightest stars. A least-squares solution of v = Kr + X cos α cos δ + Y sin α cos δ + Z sin δ, giving K ≈ 465 ± 50 km/s per million parsecs from the 24 objects and 513 ± 60 from 9 groups, with the Sun’s motion (X, Y, Z) solved at the same time; Hubble’s round value K = 500. Residuals of about 150 km/s, read as the nebulae’s own motions. Table 2: 22 more nebulae with velocities only; the relation run backwards gives their distances and absolute magnitudes, whose distribution matches Table 1’s. Humason’s first far nebula, NGC 7619 at 3779 km/s.
Secondary: a method, as argument. Distances come from the brightness of the brightest stars a nebula can be resolved into, on the assumption that the brightest stars in any such nebula are about the same true brightness (M = −6.3); Cepheids for the nearest; the average brightness of nebulae for the Virgo cluster. Velocities come from the shift of absorption lines in the nebula’s spectrum. The game puts both instruments in the player’s hands.
A counterintuitive result, and a pattern. Believed in 1929: the nebulae’s radial velocities were a puzzle, a “K term” of several hundred km/s that would not sit still, with the sun’s own motion through the nebulae confusing the picture; velocity and distance had been suspected of being related, but “so far the results have not been convincing”. The paper: once distances are trusted, the velocities line up with them. The farther the nebula, the faster it recedes, about 500 km/s for every million parsecs, and the ones that seem to approach are nearby ones whose approach is mostly our own motion. Hubble himself stops short of saying what it means (“the possibility that the velocity-distance relation may represent the de Sitter effect”). The game ends where he ended.
Through a big telescope you can see faint smudges of light far beyond our own stars. Some of them are coming towards us and some are going away, and nobody could see any order in it. You have twelve nights at the telescope. Each night you can point at one smudge, work out how far away it is from how bright its brightest stars look, and work out how fast it is moving from how far the dark lines in its light have slid towards the red. Each smudge becomes a dot on a chart. If you only look at the near, bright, easy ones, the dots are a cloud and the chart says nothing. If you spend your nights on the faint, far ones, the dots climb: the farther the smudge, the faster it is going away, and the nearby ones that seemed to be coming towards us were mostly the Sun moving. Then a colleague brings you a smudge far beyond any you measured, and you have to say how fast it is going before he tells you.
| Game | Position | Format | Feedback device | Chassis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cantor’s Bargain (cantor) | agent (the constructor of E0, in a contest) | strategic | the strike (rows struck in the Lister’s book) | fairground bill (Loud): big-top red, cream, ink, brass gold, teal; Rye + Alfa Slab One + Work Sans; ticket buttons |
| Watson’s Cardboard (dna) | experimenter (builds the model) | discovery, closed by a real-time copy | the rails (two ribbons bow, pinch, run straight) | cardboard model kit on kraft (Drawn): Permanent Marker + Courier Prime; luggage-tag buttons |
| Einstein’s Flower Merchant (einstein) | agent (dispatcher choosing boosters) | discovery, then a committed order book | two clocks and the race of the light beam | Swiss grid poster (Austere): paper, ink, signal red, light yellow; Archivo; flat square ink buttons |
What this game does differently.
Aim (start screen, top of play screen, first line of How to play): Find out whether the far nebulae drift at random or whether their speed is tied to their distance. Twelve nights. Then say how fast.
Verdict (the end screen leads with these, in words):
The yardstick during play is the plate itself: after every night the player sees whether the new dot sits on a rising line or in a cloud, and the nights remaining. At the end, the rate in the aim’s units (km/s per million parsecs) against Hubble’s.
A. The Observer (experimenter, discovery under a budget). Controls: which nebula to point at (tap on the sky), the eyepiece dial (trial distance until the comparison star matches the nebula’s brightest star), the spectrograph slide (until the nebula’s dark lines sit over the comparison lines). Deliberation: which nebula is worth a night, given what the plate shows so far and how many nights remain; the far ones cost two or three nights. Sees: a dot drop onto the plate. Discovery moment: with two or three far nebulae on the plate, the dots stop being a cloud and climb; then the Sun’s motion comes off and the approaching nearby ones turn out to be standing still or receding. Fun: agency (the instruments are under the thumb), anticipation (where will this dot land), discovery (the climb), mastery (a second game spends its nights on the far ones from the start). Replay: a different allocation; the far-first strategy and the near-first strategy produce different plates and different verdicts.
B. The Sun’s Motion (controller, challenge). The player is handed Hubble’s 24 raw velocities on the plate and three dials: the Sun’s speed, its direction, and K. Aim: make the residuals as small as possible. Deliberation: trade the Sun against K. Discovery: there is one setting where the cloud becomes a line, and K is not zero. Fun: agency, discovery. Replay: none worth having; the optimum is unique. Dull in the walkthrough: dial fiddling with nothing at stake and no instrument.
C. The Spectrograph Alone (subject/skill, real time) — the reckless one. No sky, no plate, no words: a spectrum strip scrolls in; the player drags the comparison lines onto the dark lines against a clock; velocity reads out; a sound rises with the shift. Then a second strip, fainter, with wider lines, from farther away; then a third. After six, the distances are revealed and the six readings are placed on the plate. The player has been doing Humason’s job without knowing it. Fun: mastery, anticipation. Discovery arrives only at the reveal, which makes the stretch before it a skill test about nothing. Given up: the wordless screen and the clock. Kept from it: the spectrograph as a drag-to-align instrument whose lines get broad and shallow for faint nebulae, and the last spectrum, Humason’s, whose shift is so large the lines nearly leave the frame.
A, the pick. 0:00. A black screen, stars, a title in brass capitals: HUBBLE’S TWELVE NIGHTS. Under it one line: the aim. A brass plate: BEGIN. The stranger taps. 0:10. The sky: about two dozen small smudges, some bright and large, most faint. Across the top: Night 1 of 12. Tap a nebula. A short orientation: the bright ones take one night, the faint ones two or three; nights left shown as twelve lamps. The stranger taps the biggest, brightest smudge (Andromeda, M31). 0:20. The eyepiece: a round field, the nebula resolved into points of light, one of them picked out as THE BRIGHTEST STAR; beside it a comparison star in a small circle and a dial under it marked in millions of parsecs. Turn the dial until the comparison star is as bright as the brightest star. They drag; the comparison star dims as the dial runs out; they go back; the two look alike; a thin ring glows. They press READ. 0:45. The spectrograph: a strip of grainy light with two dark lines; under it two amber lines, the comparison. Slide the strip until its dark lines sit over the amber ones. They drag; the dark lines slide; they stop over the amber; the readout says coming toward us, about 200 km/s. READ. 1:05. The plate: axes labelled DISTANCE and SPEED, one dot low down, left of centre, below the zero line. One nebula. Nothing to see yet. 11 nights left. The stranger wonders what the chart is for, and taps the next bright smudge. 1:10–2:30. Three more bright ones: dots cluster low on the left, two above zero, one below. The plate says: Four nebulae, all nearby. A cloud so far. The stranger frowns: this is not telling me anything. They look at the faint smudges and the note that one costs three nights. They weigh it: eight nights left, three for one far one. They take it. 2:45. The eyepiece for a Virgo nebula: the field is faint and grainy, the brightest star is barely there; matching is harder. The spectrograph: the lines are shallow and wide, and they are a long way to the right. The readout: going away, about 900 km/s. The dot lands far right and high. The farthest one you have is also the fastest. They grin. 3:30. Five nights left; they spend them on far ones: two more two-night nebulae and a one-night. The dots climb. 4:30. Nights over. Something is in the way: the Sun itself moves through space at about 300 km/s. Take it out. They press; the dots slide; the approaching ones rise to the zero line or above. Now set the rate. A dial swings a line up from flat through the dots. They stop it where it fits. COMMIT. 4:50. Humason has a new nebula, seven million parsecs out, beyond anything you measured. How fast? The line says about 3,500; they commit. The spectrograph opens: the dark lines slide a very long way right. 3,800 km/s. 5:10. The verdict.
B, the runner-up. 0:00. Title, aim: Make the cloud a line. 0:10. The plate with 24 dots and three dials. The stranger moves the first dial (Sun’s speed); the dots shuffle up and down. The second (direction); they shuffle differently. The third (K); a line tilts. What am I doing? They move things until a number at the bottom, the scatter, is smallest. 1:30. It is smallest near K = 500 and a Sun speed of 300. So? The stranger has moved sliders to minimise a number. They did not measure anything, and the one thing they learned, that the dots become a line at a particular setting, is the game telling them the answer with extra steps. Dead by 1:30.
A, The Observer. The player does what the paper did, with the paper’s instruments, under the paper’s own constraint (the far nebulae are the ones that settle the question, and they are the hardest to get). Real deliberation: a budget allocation that the paper itself comments on (“new data on more distant objects will be required”). The discovery lands inside the play: the climb of the dots, then the Sun’s motion coming off. The sentence afterwards has no “guess”: I measured the nebulae, the far ones were the fast ones, and I set the rate. Originality: no game in the table has had a perceptual instrument the player reads.
Author test. Hubble would recognise his brightest-star criterion with M = −6.3, his K term and solar motion solved together, his Table 1 nebulae, his Figure 1, and Humason’s NGC 7619 at the end as the paper’s own last word. He would enjoy watching a player waste four nights on bright nearby nebulae and then realise the Virgo cluster is where the answer is. The colleague who knows the answer still has to match the lines, and still has to choose where to spend the nights.
Runner-up: B. Switch if the author wants the game to be about the joint solution for solar motion and K, the paper’s statistical move, rather than about the observing. It would need a stake, and the walkthrough found none.
What the reckless concept would have given. C’s wordless real-time spectrograph would have put Humason’s craft under the thumb with no text. Kept: the drag-to-align spectrograph, lines that broaden for faint nebulae, and the climactic spectrum whose shift is enormous. Given up: the clock, the sound, and the screen with no words.
One session of about five minutes, no retry past the end (a NEW GAME button starts a fresh sky from a new seed).
Presets: none; the sky is the paper’s 24 nebulae every time. The seed varies the instruments’ graininess, the pattern of the lamps, and which nebula the orientation line first points to, not the data. Score: no running total; the rate against Hubble’s at the end.
Register: an observatory at night (Instrument family, as given). It comes from the paper’s setting: Mount Wilson, the 100-inch, photographic plates, a spectrograph with an iron-arc comparison, a chart drawn by hand in a ledger. Instrument means the data are drawn, not illustrated: the sky is the 24 nebulae at their places, the eyepiece field is the magnitude, the spectrum is the shift, the plate is Figure 1.
#070B14 (ground); starlight #E8EEF8 (stars, spectra, text); arc amber #F2A33A (comparison lines, the brightest-star ring, dial marks); shift red #E5484D (the shift readout, receding dots and arrows, the rate line); brass #B08D57 (title, rims, buttons, lamps). Blue #6EA8FF for “approaching” only, before the Sun’s motion comes off.Table 2 (22 nebulae with velocities only; distances derived from K; the matching distributions of absolute magnitudes), mentioned in About as the paper’s check. The two solutions (24 objects, 9 groups): the game uses the 24-object solar motion and lets the player set K. The Cepheid distances for the nearest six and the cluster-luminosity distance for Virgo: the game’s eyepiece reads every nebula by the brightest-star criterion, with the table’s r as truth. Lundmark’s earlier solution; the galactic rotation remark; the de Sitter discussion beyond one line on the end screen. The measured magnitudes of whole nebulae (m_t) and their absolute magnitudes.
Reconstructed. The game runs on Hubble’s Table 1 as truth (24 nebulae, distances and velocities), the paper’s brightest-star criterion (M = −6.3) for the eyepiece, the first-order Doppler shift of Ca II H and K for the spectrograph, and the paper’s own 24-object solution for the Sun’s motion. Nothing is simulated beyond the player’s own readings.
Which discoveries follow from the paper and which from the rules. The climb of the dots and the effect of the Sun’s motion follow from Table 1 and the paper’s solution; the calibration recovers both from the table. The lesson that Virgo-only shows nothing follows from the data (all four at 2.0 million parsecs) and not from our costs. The lesson that near-only shows a cloud until the Sun comes off follows from the data too (raw correlation 0.42 among the eleven cheapest, 0.75 corrected). What the rules add is the scarcity: that the far nebulae cost more. Robustness: with 9 or 15 nights instead of 12 the mixed strategy still shows the relation (checks H5), and over 300 seeds of reading noise within the rings the mixed strategy’s K stays within 300–600 (H6).
Plan: (P1) the brightest-star criterion reproduces Table 1’s distances from its m_s column within 12%; (P2) Hubble’s four-unknown solution on Table 1 with catalogue coordinates reproduces K = 465 ± 50, X, Y, Z within their printed errors, V0 ≈ 306, residuals ≈ 150; (P3) the through-origin fit on corrected velocities lands in the span of his two solutions; (P4) NGC 7619: 3779 corrects to about 3910, and 3910/500 = 7.8, M = −17.65; (P5) the spectrograph round-trips and 1000 km/s moves K by 13 Å; (P6) correction removes the approaching nebulae; then costs, budget, heuristics, words, seeds.
Result (calibration-result.txt): 45 passed, 0 failed. The four-parameter solution on the transcribed table gives K = 465, X = −69, Y = +235, Z = −200, V0 = 317, mean residual 150, against the paper’s 465, −65, +226, −195, 306, 150.
Heuristics (noisy readings within the rings; K through the origin after the Sun’s motion is taken out):
| strategy | nebulae | farthest | K | corr |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| nearest and cheapest first | 11 | 0.86 | 502 | 0.75 (raw, before the Sun: 0.42) |
| farthest first (= the four Virgo) | 4 | 2.26 | 393 | 0.01 |
| alternate far and near | 6 | 2.25 | 360 | 0.99 |
| random order | 5 | 2.25 | 394 | 0.57 |
| all 24, exact (Hubble’s table) | 24 | 2.00 | 465 | 0.84 |
The decisions matter: the same twelve nights give a plate that shows nothing, a plate that shows the relation only after the Sun’s step, or a plate that shows it plainly. Budget and costs were kept at 12 and 1/2/3 after this table; the memo’s plan of “far ones cost more” survived, and the far-first trap (all at one distance) was added to the plate’s words.
mechanism.js), calibration (calibration.js) run in Node: 45/45 after two rounds. The first run exposed the Virgo-at-one-distance fact and the near-only-after-Sun fact; the plate’s words and the verdict were rewritten to say both honestly.loop.js, loop-log.txt): seven nights, the Sun, the rate, Humason, the verdict; every action changes the printed plate and says what happened.build.py inlines the mechanism verbatim and checks it byte for byte.screenshot-*.png. Fixes from them: plate margin for the “1000” tick, axis labels moved off the ticks, duplicate SVG gradient ids across hidden screens (Humason’s strip had lost its continuum), the marker label.session-test.js, session-log.txt): three near then three far nebulae, help opened from the eyepiece and returned to it, the Sun step, the rate at 470, the prediction, Humason’s spectrum, the verdict, About and back, a new game. No page errors (the visitor counter’s script is blocked in the sandbox, as expected); no horizontal scroll at 380 px. Length about five minutes, estimated.Self-review: the aim can be stated from the start screen alone; the discovery (“The farther, the faster.”) from the top of the end screen alone; the look resembles no game in the table.
A first play found the instruments felt like guessing: the task was not self-evident from the picture, and nothing afterwards said whether a reading had been close. Five changes, in the order given:
comparisonWords).Calibration after the revision: 50 passed, 0 failed (five new checks on the descriptive words, Hubble’s points and the comparison sentence). Browser session rerun with the demonstrations: no page errors, no horizontal scroll at 380 px; new screenshots screenshot-eyepiece-demo.png, screenshot-spectrograph-demo.png, and the plate with Hubble’s dotted dots in screenshot-plate-first-far.png.
The first revision made the instruments grade the player in real time: a glow and “the halves match” or “on the bars” as soon as the dial came within tolerance. That took the judgement away from the player, who then hunted the glow instead of looking. Changed, and nothing else:
Reason: the instrument explains itself once and then leaves the judgement to the player, as it did for Hubble. A reading is an act of judgement with a consequence on the plate, not a target to hit.
Calibration after this revision: 52 passed, 0 failed. The session script no longer relies on any match state: the scripted player sets each dial to the true value times a small deliberate error, checks that the readouts carry no match words, that no glow is visible during play, and that both READ buttons are enabled after the demonstration; no page errors, no horizontal scroll at 380 px.
The previous version hid the spectrograph’s rest position in a faint dashed outline that nobody could see, and the eyepiece’s dial was a bare number. The player must see the instrument’s parts and own the judgement. Changed, on the two instruments only:
screwWords in the mechanism). Faint nebulae keep broader, shallower bars with some grain; the bars stay the darkest thing in the strip.Calibration: 53 passed, 0 failed (one new check on the screw’s readout). The session script taps through both night-one stagings, screenshots each of the three pictures for each instrument (screenshot-eyepiece-stage1/2/3.png, screenshot-spectrograph-stage1/2/3.png), then plays six nights by its own judgement; it asserts no match words in the readouts, no glow and no dashed outline in the strip, and both READ buttons enabled; no page errors, no horizontal scroll at 380 px.
Fourth revision, wording only: the later nights’ spectrograph line no longer says where the crosshairs belong; “plate” is the photograph only and the diagram of dots is “the chart” everywhere (screens, Help, mechanism words, verdict); the rate control is “the ruler”, laid through the dots; Humason’s is “the faintest spectrum yet taken”. Calibration 53/53, session rerun, screenshots refreshed.