Hanover, 23 November 1697

Leibniz’s Fullest World

Leibniz asked why there is a world at all, and why this one. Looking back in time never answers it: every state of the world is copied from the one before, for ever.

So he looked at what wants to exist. Every possible thing pushes to be, as hard as there is of it. Not all of them can be together.

The world that exists, he says, is the set of things that holds the most.

Tap a thing to let it be.
Tap it again to put it out.
Then take a torch into worlds already made.

Bring as much into existence as will fit.

Built on Lloyd Strickland’s translation of On the ultimate origination of things (2014), leibniz-translations.com. The game is dedicated to him.

Bring as much into existence as will fit.
The skies · 1 of 3

Light up the sky.

ring: could be · lit: exists · faded: shut out · line: cannot both be

Let it be: stop here. The world is what you lit, no more; then it is judged.

Bring as much into existence as will fit.
The salt mine · 1 of 2

A world already made.

Choose the other star: the small one goes out, and the big one comes in if nothing else holds it.

The verdict

What Leibniz says
The two halves
What you found
Where you part
Had yours stood
The covered picture
Your three skies beside the best

How to play

Bring as much into existence as will fit.

Five worlds, drawn fresh every game, in two halves: the skies, where you make the world, and the salt mine, where you stand inside one already made. In the three skies Each ring is a thing that could exist; the bigger the ring, the more there is of it. Some pairs cannot both exist, and nothing tells you which in advance: you find out by letting things be.

Tap a ring to let that thing be. It lights up. Anything it cannot be with goes dark, with a red line to the thing that shut it out; the line stays, so you know that pair from then on. Tap a lit star to put it out again: a step back. Whatever it was holding down can be again.

The bar under the sky shows how much light your world holds. Let it be ends the world: it holds exactly what you lit, nothing more. Then the best possible world appears next to yours, the fullest set of things that can be together, with every line and every number shown.

The third sky arrives already filled, heaviest first, and nothing left can be. Making it fuller means putting something out, then letting in what that frees.

The fourth world is not yours to make. A world already made, in the dark: a small star lit, a big one dark, a line between them, and three more lines leading from the big one into the dark. Whatever is at their ends is what decides: a lit star there holds the big one down; a dark thing there holds nothing. One torch lies in the dark: drag it to where you want it struck, and for a few seconds the stars and lines around it show, faintly, before it dies. It cannot reach the ends from the big star; you have to pick a line. When you are done looking, choose: the other star (the small one goes out, and the big one comes in if nothing else holds it), or leave it. You see what that did, in the dark; then the cover lifts; then you see the twin, another world with exactly the same opening and the other truth. The salt mine has two rounds, each a fresh world with its own torch.

At the end, your score in Leibniz's own measure: the light your five worlds hold, against the light the five best possible worlds hold.

About

The paper. G. W. Leibniz, De rerum originatione radicali (On the ultimate origination of things), 23 November 1697. Manuscript LH 4, 1, 10 Bl. 2–4, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Bibliothek, Hanover; first printed in Erdmann's Opera philosophica (1840), 147–150; Gerhardt, Die philosophischen Schriften VII, 302–308. Read in Lloyd Strickland's translation from the Latin (© 2014, complete, with the manuscript's deletions in the notes), published at leibniz-translations.com, and quoted here with his permission; the game's words for Leibniz's ideas lean on his. No DOI. Game built from this paper; the paper is the authority where the two disagree.

What the paper says

Why is there a world at all, and why this one? Not because of anything in the world: every state is copied from the one before, like a geometry textbook copied from an earlier copy, and however far back you go you never reach a reason why there are books at all. So the reason lies outside the series, in something that exists of necessity. Then the part this game plays: how that reason picks a world. Every possible thing has a claim to exist, a push, in proportion to how much reality there is in it. Not all possibles can exist together. What exists is the combination through which the greatest total of reality comes to be: "there is always in things a principle of determination which must be sought in maximum and minimum". Leibniz says this in the words of a game: "certain games where all the spaces on the board are to be filled according to certain rules, and where, unless you use some skill, you will in the end be excluded from certain spaces and forced to leave more spaces empty than you could have or wished to". He adds the picture of heavy bodies that settle into the arrangement of greatest total descent.

From the maximum follows his answer to the oldest objection, that the world is full of suffering and waste. The best whole is not the sum of the best parts. Cover all but a corner of a beautiful painting and you see "a confused chaos of colours"; dissonances make the music better; bitter things should be mixed in with the sweet. Afflictions are "stepping back in order to make a leap forward with greater force" (he writes the French reculer pour mieux sauter in the margin); when a part of the world is destroyed, "this very destruction and oppression is useful for achieving something greater, so that in a way we profit from our very loss". And since there is always more that is possible than has been made, progress never ends. He also tells the story of an ape that carried the infant King Christian of Denmark to the edge of a roof and, when everyone was frightened, put him back in his cradle laughing: we enjoy the danger for the restoring.

What the game does

It takes Leibniz's rule, not his board. Leibniz's possibles fail to exist together because of what they are, not because they overlap; so there is no board, and nothing is placed. A sky holds the things that could exist; each has a weight, how much there is of it, shown by its size; some pairs cannot both be. Nothing tells you which pairs in advance: a line appears once one thing has shut another out, and the numbers appear only when a world has ended. You decide what exists, and a world holds exactly what you lit, nothing more. Every sky is drawn fresh for each game, and each draw is checked before it is shown for the one thing its world is there to show. On the first sky, more wants to be than can be together, so even the best world leaves things dark. On the second, the grandest thing is the trap: it cannot be with several lesser things that together hold more than it does. On the third, the sky comes already filled by weight, heaviest first, and nothing left can be; the only way to a fuller world is to put something out and let in what that frees, and the thing to put out is never the biggest. After each sky the best possible world is shown next to yours, found by an exact search over every set. The fourth world is Leibniz's covered picture played: a world already made, in the dark, a small lit star holding a big dark one down, and three more lines leading from the big one into the dark. What is at their ends decides: a lit star there holds the big one down, a dark thing there holds nothing. One torch lies in the dark: drag it to where you want it struck, and for a few seconds the stars and lines around it show faintly before it dies; from the big star it cannot reach the ends, so you pick a line. When you are done looking you choose the other star, so that the small one goes out and the big one may be, or leave the world; you see what that did, still in the dark; then the cover lifts. Then the twin is shown beside it: another world with exactly the same opening and the other truth. In one of the two, two of the lines end in lit stars worth more than the big one together, so choosing the other star loses the small one and gains nothing; in the other all three end in dark things, nothing but the small one holds the big one, and choosing the other star lets it in. Which of the two you get is drawn at random, and the salt mine has two such rounds, each a fresh draw with its own torch. The evidence runs one way: a torch can show the big one held, for certain, and can never show it free, since the lines it did not reach stay dark.

At the end, a score in Leibniz's own measure: the light your five worlds hold, against the light the five best possible worlds hold together, with the salt-mine worlds counted at what they held after your act. And a word on the two halves: the skies play the paper's argument, what "best" means; the salt mine plays the paper's answer to the objection from suffering, that from inside you cannot tell. Leibniz holds both, and concludes from the first that the world is the best whatever the second shows you.

What kind of mechanism this is

Toy. The game runs a model built to illustrate the paper's argument, and where the argument had to be made exact, the toy chose: a thing's reality is a number (Leibniz: "perfection is nothing other than quantity of essence"); the only incompatibility is a listed pair that cannot both exist; the skies, their weights and their pairs are drawn by a generator of ours, each draw proved by the headless check to hold the one point its world is there to show, over hundreds of draws.

What is cut, and where the game departs

The first argument (the copied books and the necessary being) is three lines on the start screen. The equilateral triangle, the shortest path, the sphere, the laws of motion, the commonwealth of minds and the law of justice are not played; the covered picture is the fourth world. Leibniz's possibles do not get chosen by a hand; the game gives you the hand and then shows the maximum, and lets weight act without a hand once, in the third sky's filling (heaviest first, our picture of his heavy bodies). Nothing else is ever chosen for you. "Best possible world", "possible", "step back" are his words; "light", "lit", "dark", "waiting", "Let it be", the torch is the game's.

Making of

Built with Claude under the paper-to-game skill, November 2026; a first build packed shapes on a board and was replaced by this one. Every number the game uses, and the generator's ranges, sit in a commented block at the top of mechanism.js, with the headless check that proves the lessons over two hundred draws (calibration.js). The design memo is in the repository. Type: Space Grotesk (Florian Karsten, SIL Open Font License), embedded.